arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1609.05567physics.class-ph
收藏

费曼对静电屏蔽的分析正确吗?

Is Feynman's Analysis of Electrostatic Screening Correct?

Kris Subbarao, Sukhbir Mahajan

摘要:

在最近一篇关于静电屏蔽的论文中,Chapman、Hewett和Trefethen认为Feynman对这种效应的分析是不正确的。费曼分析了由一排极细的导线构成的屏蔽。他们声称费曼使用了错误的边界条件,使他的分析无效。本文着重指出,费曼解是一个格林函数,通过它可以理解任意截面的有限厚导线在适当边界条件下的电势行为。这说明费曼的主要处理结论确实是正确的。将平行板电容器与其中一个板替换为一排导线的类比提供了对费曼论点的更直观的理解。作为法拉第笼的模型,有限数量的金属丝排列成一个环的情况(费曼没有处理)是不同的。径向坐标下的解的结构已经表明,人们不应该期望指数行为,进一步的分析证实了这一点。在文献中似乎有矛盾的结果,其屏蔽行为在外部电荷或领域的存在。

英文摘要:

In a recent paper on electrostatic shielding, Chapman, Hewett and Trefethen present arguments that the analysis of this effect by Feynman is incorrect. Feynman analyzed shielding by a row of infinitesimally thin wires. They claim that Feynman used the wrong boundary conditions invalidating his analysis. In this paper we emphasize that Feynman's solution is a Green's function through which behavior of the potential due to finite thickness wires of arbitrary cross-section with appropriate boundary condition can be understood. This shows that the main conclusions of Feynman's treatment are indeed correct. Analogy to a parallel plate capacitor with one of the plates replaced by a row of wires provides a more intuitive understanding of Feynman's argument. The case of a finite number of wires arranged in a ring (not treated by Feynman), as a model of Faraday cage, is different. The structure of the solution in radial coordinates already suggests that one should not expect exponential behavior and further analysis confirms this. There appear to be contradictory results in the literature for its screening behavior in the presence of external charges or fields.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑