两个基准交易模型中的静态与适应性最优执行策略
Static vs adapted optimal execution strategies in two benchmark trading models
摘要:
我们考虑了交易执行问题在两个不同类别中的最优解决方案:i)完全适应或自适应,ii)确定性或静态策略,并对它们进行比较。我们在两个不同的基准模型中这样做。第一个模型是一个离散的时间框架与信息流过程,处理永久性和临时性的影响,最大限度地减少预期的贸易成本。第二个模型是一个连续时间框架,目标函数是预期成本和风险价值(或预期损失)类型风险标准的总和。最优适应解在Bertsimas和Lo(1998)以及Gatheral和Schied(2011)的原始作品中的两个框架中都是已知的。在本文中,我们得出的最佳静态策略的基准模型,我们定量研究的最优性的改善时,从静态策略完全适应。我们的结论是,在我们研究的基准模型中,除了模型或影响参数的极端不切实际的情况外,差异是不相关的。这间接地证实了在Almgren和Chriss(2000)的类似框架中,可以很好地导出静态最优解,正如这些作者所做的那样,而不是完全适应的解,因为静态解恰好是易处理的,并且以封闭形式已知。
英文摘要:
We consider the optimal solutions to the trade execution problem in the two different classes of i) fully adapted or adaptive and ii) deterministic or static strategies, comparing them. We do this in two different benchmark models. The first model is a discrete time framework with an information flow process, dealing with both permanent and temporary impact, minimizing the expected cost of the trade. The second model is a continuous time framework where the objective function is the sum of the expected cost and a value at risk (or expected shortfall) type risk criterion. Optimal adapted solutions are known in both frameworks from the original works of Bertsimas and Lo (1998) and Gatheral and Schied (2011). In this paper we derive the optimal static strategies for both benchmark models and we study quantitatively the improvement in optimality when moving from static strategies to fully adapted ones. We conclude that, in the benchmark models we study, the difference is not relevant, except for extreme unrealistic cases for the model or impact parameters. This indirectly confirms that in the similar framework of Almgren and Chriss (2000) one is fine deriving a static optimal solution, as done by those authors, as opposed to a fully adapted one, since the static solution happens to be tractable and known in closed form.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。