arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1608.06897q-bio.QM
收藏

生物科学中的全计算再现:方法、软件和蛋白质生物学案例研究

Full Computational Reproducibility in Biological Science: Methods, Software and a Case Study in Protein Biology

Les Hatton, Gregory Warr

摘要:

科学结果的独立计算再现性在科学进步中正迅速变得至关重要,因为计算本身在科学的许多分支中发挥着越来越重要的作用。从历史上看,再现性遵循了熟悉的波普尔模型[38],即理论不能通过科学测试来验证,它只能被证伪。最后,这意味着,如果一个实验不能独立地复制到某种令人满意的精度水平,它的价值基本上是不可量化的;残酷地说,它不可能确定其科学价值。软件在大多数科学工作中的迅速出现增加了一个新的、特别不透明的复杂性层[29]。尽管最近对许多科学领域感兴趣,但重点仍然更多地放在程序,限制和讨论上[12,14,16,29,30,37,41],反映了大多数科学期刊在软件方面缺乏经验,而不是如何实际实现计算再现性的细节,对此似乎有相对较少的指导性示例[6,10,17]。在考虑基本原则后,在这里,我们展示了如何在实践中实现完整的计算再现性在每个阶段使用开放的SwissProt蛋白质数据库上的一个多千兆字节的蛋白质研究的案例研究,从数据下载一直到个人的数字复制作为一般科学计算的范例。

英文摘要:

Independent computational reproducibility of scientific results is rapidly becoming of pivotal importance in scientific progress as computation itself plays a more and more central role in so many branches of science. Historically, reproducibility has followed the familiar Popperian [38] model whereby theory cannot be verified by scientific testing, it can only be falsified. Ultimately, this implies that if an experiment cannot be reproduced independently to some satisfactory level of precision, its value is essentially unquantifiable; put brutally, it is impossible to determine its scientific value. The burgeoning presence of software in most scientific work adds a new and particularly opaque layer of complexity [29]. In spite of much recent interest in many scientific areas, emphasis remains more on procedures, strictures and discussion [12, 14, 16, 29, 30, 37, 41], reflecting the inexperience of most scientific journals when it comes to software, rather than the details of how computational reproducibility is actually achieved, for which there appear to be relatively few guiding examples [6, 10, 17]. After considering basic principles, here we show how full computational reproducibility can be achieved in practice at every stage using a case study of a multi-gigabyte protein study on the open SwissProt protein database, from data download all the way to individual figure by figure reproduction as an exemplar for general scientific computation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑