arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1608.00944cs.DCcs.SE
收藏

分布式还是单片?一个计算体系结构决策框架

Distributed or Monolithic? A Computational Architecture Decision Framework

Mohsen Mosleh, Kia Dalili, Babak Heydari

摘要:

分布式架构在许多复杂的技术和社会技术系统中无处不在,因为它们在改善不确定性管理,适应多个利益相关者以及增加可扩展性和可演化性方面发挥了作用。这种与单片架构的背离为系统提供了更大的灵活性和鲁棒性,以响应其在其寿命期间可能面临的不确定性。分布式架构不仅提供了好处,因为它会增加系统的成本和复杂性,并导致潜在的不稳定性。然而,这种权衡背后的机制类似于广泛研究的从集成到模块化架构的过渡。在本文中,我们使用一个概念性的决策框架,统一的模块化和分布式架构的五阶段系统架构频谱。我们添加了一个广泛的计算层的框架,并解释这可以提高决策的架构的模块化水平。然后,我们将其应用于美国国防高级研究计划局(DARPA)的分馏卫星计划的简化演示。通过模拟,我们计算的净价值,获得(或失去)从单片架构迁移到分布式架构,并显示这个值如何变化的环境和各种系统参数的不确定性的函数。此外,考虑到分布式架构固有的不确定性,我们使用风险价值作为失去分布式架构价值的风险度量。

英文摘要:

Distributed architectures have become ubiquitous in many complex technical and socio-technical systems because of their role in improving uncertainty management, accommodating multiple stakeholders, and increasing scalability and evolvability. This departure from monolithic architectures provides a system with more flexibility and robustness in response to uncertainties that it may confront during its lifetime. Distributed architecture does not provide benefits only, as it can increase cost and complexity of the system and result in potential instabilities. The mechanisms behind this trade-off, however, are analogous to those of the widely-studied transition from integrated to modular architectures. In this paper, we use a conceptual decision framework that unifies modularity and distributed architecture on a five-stage systems architecture spectrum. We add an extensive computational layer to the framework and explain how this can enhance decision making about the level of modularity of the architecture. We then apply it to a simplified demonstration of the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency (DARPA) fractionated satellite program. Through simulation, we calculate the net value that is gained (or lost) by migrating from a monolithic architecture to a distributed architecture and show how this value changes as a function of uncertainties in the environment and various system parameters. Additionally, we use Value at Risk as a measure for the risk of losing the value of distributed architecture, given its inherent uncertainty.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑