科学的记忆:通货膨胀、近视和知识网络
The Memory of Science: Inflation, Myopia, and the Knowledge Network
摘要:
科学是一个不断增长的系统,出版物的年增长率约为4%,每份出版物的参考文献数量的年增长率约为1.8%。这些趋势加在一起,相当于参考文献供应总量在12年内翻了一番,从而对从研究人员到机构的传统科学成果评估方法提出了挑战。在此背景下,我们分析了一个引文网络,其中包括1965-2012年期间3260万出版物产生的8.37亿次引用,从而对科学中的“注意力经济”进行了时间分析。与以前的研究不同,我们分析了参考年龄的整个概率分布-引用和引用论文之间的时间差-从而捕捉到以前被忽视的趋势。在这半个世纪的时间里,我们观察到一个缩小的范围内的关注-无论是经典和最近的文献被引用越来越少,指出社会技术过程的重要作用。为了更好地理解指数增长对底层知识网络的影响,我们开发了一个基于网络的模型,其特点是通过出版物的参考文献列表重定向科学注意力,并对几个经验基准验证模型。然后,我们使用该模型来测试真正的范式转变的因果关系的影响,从而为科学政策分析提供指导。特别是,我们展示了科学产出增长率的扰动如何影响参考年龄分布和庞大的科学引文网络作为知识搜索和检索的辅助工具的功能。为了解释科学的膨胀,我们的研究指出,有必要对用于评估引文影响的计数方法进行系统性的改革-特别是在评估科学职业的情况下,这可能跨越几十年,因此有几个倍增期。
英文摘要:
Science is a growing system, exhibiting ~4% annual growth in publications and ~1.8% annual growth in the number of references per publication. Combined these trends correspond to a 12-year doubling period in the total supply of references, thereby challenging traditional methods of evaluating scientific production, from researchers to institutions. Against this background, we analyzed a citation network comprised of 837 million references produced by 32.6 million publications over the period 1965-2012, allowing for a temporal analysis of the `attention economy' in science. Unlike previous studies, we analyzed the entire probability distribution of reference ages - the time difference between a citing and cited paper - thereby capturing previously overlooked trends. Over this half-century period we observe a narrowing range of attention - both classic and recent literature are being cited increasingly less, pointing to the important role of socio-technical processes. To better understand the impact of exponential growth on the underlying knowledge network we develop a network-based model, featuring the redirection of scientific attention via publications' reference lists, and validate the model against several empirical benchmarks. We then use the model to test the causal impact of real paradigm shifts, thereby providing guidance for science policy analysis. In particular, we show how perturbations to the growth rate of scientific output affects the reference age distribution and the functionality of the vast science citation network as an aid for the search & retrieval of knowledge. In order to account for the inflation of science, our study points to the need for a systemic overhaul of the counting methods used to evaluate citation impact - especially in the case of evaluating science careers, which can span several decades and thus several doubling periods.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。