对BCBS操作风险新标准化方法提案的评论
Comments on the BCBS proposal for a New Standardized Approach for Operational Risk
摘要:
2016年3月4日,巴塞尔银行监管委员会发布了一份咨询文件,其中引入了一种称为标准化计量方法(SMA)的新方法来计算银行的操作风险监管资本。在本文中,SMA的行为在各种假设和现实条件下进行了研究,表明新方法的简单性在其他方面代价很大:我们发现SMA不能对银行风险状况的变化做出适当的反应,也不能区分银行之间可能的风险状况范围; SMA资本结果在银行间的变化通常比之前AMA拟合损失数据的选项更大; SMA可能导致银行相对于之前AMA标准对运营风险的保险过度或不足。最后,我们认为,SMA不仅在其衡量风险的能力方面是倒退的,但也许更重要的是,它未能在管理行为和资本要求之间建立任何联系。
英文摘要:
On March 4th 2016 the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision published a consultative document where a new methodology, called the Standardized Measurement Approach (SMA), is introduced for computing Operational Risk regulatory capital for banks. In this note, the behavior of the SMA is studied under a variety of hypothetical and realistic conditions, showing that the simplicity of the new approach is very costly on other aspects: we find that the SMA does not respond appropriately to changes in the risk profile of a bank, nor is it capable of differentiating among the range of possible risk profiles across banks; that SMA capital results generally appear to be more variable across banks than the previous AMA option of fitting the loss data; that the SMA can result in banks over- or under-insuring against operational risks relative to previous AMA standards. Finally, we argue that the SMA is not only retrograde in terms of its capability to measure risk, but perhaps more importantly, it fails to create any link between management actions and capital requirement.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。