回复K.A.的评论Duderstadt等人,“高通量、硬光谱太阳质子事件引起的大气离子及其在ice core档案中的可能出现”
Reply to comment by K.A. Duderstadt et al. on "Atmospheric ionization by high-fluence, hard spectrum solar proton events and their probable appearance in the ice core archive"
摘要:
Duderstadt等人[2016 b]评论说,Melott等人[2016]对太阳质子事件(SPE)形成硝酸盐的研究以及与冰芯档案的比较是“根本性缺陷”,因为它不包括平流层中预先存在的HNO 3。我们表明,他们夸大了我们的研究结果和工业化前的硝酸水平在他们的模型中预测的增强,并未能证明这一论断。我们的可行性研究将预期的SPE硝酸盐生产与地面实况测量相匹配。不清楚他们的方法是否更现实,缺乏详细的机制并不能否定我们的结果。模型不可能比它们提供的信息更好,在这种情况下,仍然存在重大的未知数和不确定性,特别是在极地平流层云的作用和与构成低边界条件的宇宙射线的可能相互作用方面。Duderstadt等人[2014; 2016 a]使用了不完整、约束不良和不正确的初始和边界条件,并且他们继续在不确定结果的基础上进行主张。与此同时,Smart等人[2014]确定了一系列冰芯硝酸盐峰值,此后McCracken和Beer [2015]在10 Be中证实了这一点。Melott等人[2016]通过计算再现了迄今为止唯一主要球囊测量的电离分布。我们表明,我们计算的硝酸盐增强与测量结果一致,考虑到目前的不确定性水平,极端SPE可能会产生偶尔的硝酸盐峰值,增加数百%。与其重复旧的论点来驳回硝酸盐作为SPE的代理,现在是一个专门的,精细的分辨率,多参数,复制冰芯场运动来解决这一争论的时候了。
英文摘要:
Duderstadt et al. [2016b] comment that the Melott et al. [2016] study of nitrate formation by solar proton events (SPEs) and comparison with the ice core archive is "fundamentally flawed," because it does not include pre-existing HNO3 in the stratosphere. We show that they exaggerate both the enhancement predicted by our findings and pre-industrial HNO3 levels in their model, and fail to prove this assertion. Our feasibility study matched expected SPE nitrate production with ground truth measurements. It is not clear that their approach is more realistic and absence of a detailed mechanism does not disprove our results. Models can be no better than the information they are provided and in this case there continue to be significant unknowns and uncertainties, especially in the role of polar stratospheric clouds (PSCs) and possible interactions with cosmic rays that constitute lower boundary conditions. Duderstadt et al. [2014; 2016a] used incomplete, poorly-constrained and incorrect initial and boundary conditions, and they continue to advocate on the basis of uncertain results. Meanwhile, Smart et al. [2014] identified a series of ice core nitrate spikes that have since been confirmed in 10Be by McCracken and Beer [2015]. Melott et al. [2016] computationally reproduced the ionization profile of the only major balloon measurements to date. We show that our calculated nitrate enhancement is consistent with measured results, given current levels of uncertainty, and that extreme SPEs can potentially produce occasional nitrate spikes with hundreds of percent increases. Instead of repeating old arguments to dismiss nitrates as proxies of SPEs, it is past time for a dedicated, fine-resolution, multi-parameter, replicate ice core field campaign to resolve this debate.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。