arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1606.08326math.LO
收藏

从希尔伯特的量词和量词看亚里士多德的对立方

Aristotle's square of opposition in the light of Hilbert's epsilon and tau quantifiers

Fabio Pasquali, Christian Retoré

摘要:

亚里士多德在他的三段论研究和他著名的对立方中考虑了特定的量化句子。当然,亚里士多德著作中的逻辑公式不是现代的数理逻辑公式,而是自然语言的普通语句。如今,自然语言句子被转化为弗雷格定义的谓词逻辑公式,但这些弗雷格句子是否是自然语言句子的忠实表示尚不清楚。事实上,自然语言量词的通常建模并不完全符合自然语言语法,正如我们将看到的。这就是为什么希尔伯特的量词(超越了通常的量词)被用来模拟自然语言量词的原因。在这里,我们解释亚里士多德量化的句子作为希尔伯特的微积分和τ演算的公式。这就产生了两个潜在的对立方,如果一个自然条件成立,这两个方中的一个实际上是对立方,即满足对立、矛盾和次交替的关系。

英文摘要:

Aristotle considered particular quantified sentences in his study of syllogisms and in his famous square of opposition. Of course, the logical formulas in Aristotle work were not modern formulas of mathematical logic, but ordinary sentences of natural language. Nowadays natural language sentences are turned into formulas of predicate logic as defined by Frege, but, it is not clear that those Fregean sentences are faithful representations of natural language sentences. Indeed, the usual modelling of natural language quantifiers does not fully correspond to natural language syntax, as we shall see. This is the reason why Hilbert's epsilon and tau quantifiers (that go beyond usual quantifiers) have been used to model natural language quantifiers. Here we interpret Aristotle quantified sentences as formulas of Hilbert's epsilon and tau calculus. This yields to two potential squares of opposition and provided a natural condition holds, one of these two squares is actually a square of opposition i.e. satisfies the relations of contrary, contradictory, and subalternation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑