arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1603.08048cs.CLcs.SIstat.ML
收藏

“我说错什么了吗?“维基百科条目的词汇级分析,用于删除讨论

"Did I Say Something Wrong?" A Word-Level Analysis of Wikipedia Articles for Deletion Discussions

Institute for Web Science and Technologies(网络科学与技术研究所)

Michael Ruster

摘要:

本文旨在从词汇层面上对语篇讨论进行语言学分析。特别值得注意的是,要区分哪些信息对讨论有建设性贡献,哪些信息对讨论有害。因此,我们想确定“我”和“你”的消息是否是两种讨论风格的指示器。如今,这些信息经常被用于成功沟通的指导方针。虽然它们的影响已多次成功评估,但从未进行过大规模的分析。因此,我们使用Wikipedia Articles for Deletion(简称:AfD)讨论以及被阻止用户的记录,并开发了一个完全自动化的注释数据集的创建。在这个数据集中,信息被标记为建设性或破坏性。我们应用二进制分类器的数据,以确定两种讨论风格的特征词。因此,我们还探讨了代词和连词等虚词在区分两者中是否起着重要作用。我们发现,“你”的消息是一个很强的指标,破坏性的消息,符合其归因于对通信的影响。然而,我们发现“我”-消息是指示破坏性的消息,以及这是相反的,他们的归因效果。虚词的重要性既不能肯定,也不能否定。然而,研究结果表明,不同的模型可能更好地代表文本讨论中的破坏性和建设性信息。

英文摘要:

This thesis focuses on gaining linguistic insights into textual discussions on a word level. It was of special interest to distinguish messages that constructively contribute to a discussion from those that are detrimental to them. Thereby, we wanted to determine whether "I"- and "You"-messages are indicators for either of the two discussion styles. These messages are nowadays often used in guidelines for successful communication. Although their effects have been successfully evaluated multiple times, a large-scale analysis has never been conducted. Thus, we used Wikipedia Articles for Deletion (short: AfD) discussions together with the records of blocked users and developed a fully automated creation of an annotated data set. In this data set, messages were labelled either constructive or disruptive. We applied binary classifiers to the data to determine characteristic words for both discussion styles. Thereby, we also investigated whether function words like pronouns and conjunctions play an important role in distinguishing the two. We found that "You"-messages were a strong indicator for disruptive messages which matches their attributed effects on communication. However, we found "I"-messages to be indicative for disruptive messages as well which is contrary to their attributed effects. The importance of function words could neither be confirmed nor refuted. Other characteristic words for either communication style were not found. Yet, the results suggest that a different model might represent disruptive and constructive messages in textual discussions better.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑