量子力学中的反射与自监控
Reflection and Self-Monitoring in Quantum Mechanics
摘要:
专家物理学家的一个假定属性是,他们很容易从自己的错误中吸取教训。专家们不太可能在第二次被要求解决问题时犯同样的错误,特别是如果他们有正确的解决方案。在这里,我们讨论了一个案例研究,其中14个高年级本科物理学生参加荣誉级量子力学课程,在期中考试和期末考试中都给出了同样的四个问题,并向学生提供了期中问题的解决方案。期末考试的表现表明,虽然一些高年级学生在第二次考试的问题上表现得与期中考试一样好或有所提高,期末考试的成绩不如期中考试的成绩好。学生在第二次考试中的表现分布很广,这表明大多数高年级学生不会自动利用他们的错误,一个学习的机会,以及修复,扩展和组织他们的知识结构。与一个子集的学生访谈揭示了解决问题的态度,并深入了解他们的学习方法。
英文摘要:
An assumed attribute of expert physicists is that they learn readily from their own mistakes. Experts are unlikely to make the same mistakes when asked to solve a problem a second time, especially if they have had access to a correct solution. Here, we discuss a case study in which fourteen advanced undergraduate physics students taking an honors-level quantum mechanics course were given the same four problems in both a midterm and final exam. The solutions to the midterm problems were provided to students. The performance on the final exam shows that while some advanced students performed equally well or improved compared to their performance on the midterm exam on the questions administered a second time, a comparable number performed less well on the final exam than on the midterm exam. The wide distribution of students' performance on problems administered a second time suggests that most advanced students do not automatically exploit their mistakes as an opportunity for learning, and for repairing, extending, and organizing their knowledge structure. Interviews with a subset of students revealed attitudes towards problem-solving and gave insight into their approach to learning.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。