使用平方负荷、批准移除和硬币翻转批准转换的比例批准方法(PAMSAC)-使用批准投票的比例代表制的新系统
Proportional Approval Method using Squared loads, Approval removal and Coin-flip approval transformation (PAMSAC) - a new system of proportional representation using approval voting
摘要:
已经开发了几种使用批准投票的多赢家系统,但是它们每个都遭受各种问题。本文讨论了其中的六种方法。他们是满意批准投票,极小极大批准投票,比例批准投票,门罗的完全比例代表,Chamberlin-Courant规则和Ebert方法。它们都不符合比例表示(PR),强PR,单调性或正支持中的至少一个。然而,本文中描述的新方法-使用平方负载的比例批准方法,批准删除和硬币翻转批准转换(PAMSAC)-通过了所有这些。PAMSAC使用Ebert方法的平方载荷,但删除了非有益的批准以恢复单调性。它还使用硬币翻转批准转换(CFAT),其中选民针对他们批准的每个候选人被“分成”两部分,并且其中一半选民批准,另一半选民不批准选票上批准的每个候选人。这恢复了积极的支持,也使该方法等同于D 'Hondt政党投票的政党名单方法。PAMSAC在单一赢家的情况下简化为简单的批准投票。一个分数投票版本的描述,也减少到简单的分数投票在单一的赢家的情况下。
英文摘要:
Several multi-winner systems that use approval voting have been developed but they each suffer from various problems. Six of these methods are discussed in this paper. They are Satisfaction Approval Voting, Minimax Approval Voting, Proportional Approval Voting, Monroe's Fully Proportional Representation, Chamberlin-Courant's Rule, and Ebert's method. They all fail at least one of Proportional Representation (PR), strong PR, monotonicity or positive support. However, the new method described in this paper - Proportional Approval Method using Squared loads, Approval removal and Coin-flip approval transformation (PAMSAC) - passes them all. PAMSAC uses the squared loads of Ebert's method, but removes non-beneficial approvals to restore monotonicity. It also uses the Coin-Flip Approval Transformation (CFAT), where voters are "split" into two for each candidate they approve, and where one half of this split voter approves and the other half does not approve each candidate approved on the ballot. This restores positive support, and also makes the method equivalent to the D'Hondt party-list method for party voting. PAMSAC reduces to simple approval voting in the single-winner case. A score voting version is described that also reduces to simple score voting in the single-winner case.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。