arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1601.08210physics.ed-ph
收藏

物理学研究生助教评分方法的目标与实践

Physics postgraduate teaching assistants' grading approaches: Conflicting goals and practices

Emily Marshman, Alexandru Maries, Charles Henderson, Chandralekha Singh, Edit Yerushalmi

摘要:

评分可以塑造学生的学习和鼓励使用有效的解决问题的做法。教学助理(TA)通常负责学生的解决方案评分和提供反馈,因此,他们的评分的看法可能会影响物理课堂的评分实践。了解助教对评分的看法对课程开发人员以及对改进评分实践感兴趣的专业发展领导者来说是有用的。为了确定助教的评分的看法,我们使用了一个数据收集工具,旨在引起助教的考虑时,评分的决定,以及引起他们的既定目标和实际的评分做法之间可能存在的冲突。该工具的目的是阐明助教的态度,以研究为基础的评分的做法,促进有效的解决问题的方法。助教首先被要求陈述他们的总体评分目标。然后,助教在模拟环境中对学生的解决方案进行评分,同时解释和讨论他们的基本考虑。数据收集工具在助教的第一个研究生教学任命开始时进行管理,并在一个学期的教学经验后再次进行管理。我们发现,几乎所有的助教都说评分的目的是形成性的,即,评分应鼓励学生从错误中吸取教训,并将学生常见的困难告知教师。然而,当在模拟环境中做出评分决定时,大多数助教的评分考虑集中在正确性上,他们没有以鼓励使用有效解决问题方法的方式分配分数。在一个学期的教学经验中,助教对评分的看法没有明显变化。

英文摘要:

Grading can shape students' learning and encourage use of effective problem solving practices. Teaching assistants (TAs) are often responsible for grading student solutions and providing feedback, thus, their perceptions of grading may impact grading practices in the physics classroom. Understanding TAs' perceptions of grading is instrumental for curriculum developers as well as professional development leaders interested in improving grading practices. In order to identify TAs' perceptions of grading, we used a data collection tool designed to elicit TAs' considerations when making grading decisions as well as elicit possible conflicts between their stated goals and actual grading practices. The tool was designed to explicate TAs' attitudes towards research-based grading practices that promote effective problem solving approaches. TAs were first asked to state their goals for grading in general. Then, TAs graded student solutions in a simulated setting while explicating and discussing their underlying considerations. The data collection tool was administered at the beginning of TAs' first postgraduate teaching appointment and again after one semester of teaching experience. We found that almost all of the TAs stated that the purpose of grading was formative, i.e., grading should encourage students to learn from their mistakes as well as inform the instructor of common student difficulties. However, when making grading decisions in a simulated setting, the majority of TAs' grading considerations focused on correctness and they did not assign grades in a way that encourages use of effective problem solving approaches. TAs' perceptions of grading did not change significantly during one semester of teaching experience.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑