评估立法者显示偏好的差异:第107届美国参议院的案例研究
Assessing differences in legislators' revealed preferences: A case study on the 107th U.S. Senate
摘要:
点名数据被广泛用于评估立法者的偏好和意识形态,以及测试立法行为的理论。特别是,点名数据经常被用来确定立法者的公开偏好是否受到外部力量的影响,如政党压力,少数民族地位或程序规则。本文介绍了一种贝叶斯分层模型,扩展现有的空间投票模型,以测试尖锐的假设,使用与这些假设相关的后验概率的偏好差异。我们使用我们的模型来调查在第107届美国参议院中,政党多数地位的变化对参议员偏好的影响。这项分析提供的证据表明,政党关系的变化可能会影响立法者的显示偏好,但没有提供证据表明多数地位的立法者的显示偏好的效果。
英文摘要:
Roll call data are widely used to assess legislators' preferences and ideology, as well as test theories of legislative behavior. In particular, roll call data is often used to determine whether the revealed preferences of legislators are affected by outside forces such as party pressure, minority status or procedural rules. This paper describes a Bayesian hierarchical model that extends existing spatial voting models to test sharp hypotheses about differences in preferences the using posterior probabilities associated with such hypotheses. We use our model to investigate the effect of the change of party majority status during the 107th U.S. Senate on the revealed preferences of senators. This analysis provides evidence that change in party affiliation might affect the revealed preferences of legislators, but provides no evidence about the effect of majority status on the revealed preferences of legislators.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。