arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1511.08367physics.soc-phcs.DL
收藏

学术研究团体:评价其质量和评价其质量

Academic research groups: evaluation of their quality and quality of their evaluation

Bertrand Berche, Yurij Holovatch, Ralph Kenna, Olesya Mryglod

摘要:

近年来,学术研究质量的评估已经成为一个越来越重要和有影响力的业务。它通常在很大程度上决定了政府机构流入大学和类似机构的研究资金的数量,并影响学术生涯。决策者越来越依赖这种评价的结果,并受其影响。作为回应,大学管理者越来越倾向于用简单的指标来指导其各个机构在排行榜上的位置动态。然而,这些排名表往往是由报纸和杂志等非专业机构采用相当武断的衡量标准和标准编制的。诸如“临界质量”和“指标”之类的术语经常被滥用,而没有正确理解它们的实际含义。与其接受大学、系所和个人在一片专断措施的波涛汹涌的海洋上的兴衰,我们建议科学界自己有责任澄清它们的性质。在这里,我们报告了最近的尝试,通过正确定义临界质量,并显示组的大小如何影响研究质量。我们还研究了目前占主导地位的指标,并表明这些失败的可靠指标组的研究质量。

英文摘要:

In recent years, evaluation of the quality of academic research has become an increasingly important and influential business. It determines, often to a large extent, the amount of research funding flowing into universities and similar institutes from governmental agencies and it impacts upon academic careers. Policy makers are becoming increasingly reliant upon, and influenced by, the outcomes of such evaluations. In response, university managers are increasingly attracted to simple indicators as guides to the dynamics of the positions of their various institutions in league tables. However, these league tables are frequently drawn up by inexpert bodies such as newspapers and magazines, using rather arbitrary measures and criteria. Terms such as "critical mass' and "metrics" are often bandied about without proper understanding of what they actually mean. Rather than accepting the rise and fall of universities, departments and individuals on a turbulent sea of arbitrary measures, we suggest it is incumbent upon the scientific community itself to clarify their nature. Here we report on recent attempts to do that by properly defining critical mass and showing how group size influences research quality. We also examine currently predominant metrics and show that these fail as reliable indicators of group research quality.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑