arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1507.05602cs.DLphysics.data-anphysics.soc-ph
收藏

科研绩效分析:一个新的补充指标的提出

Analyzing research performance: proposition of a new complementary index

Shaon Sahoo

摘要:

一个与许多小组合作的研究人员通常会比一个把所有时间都花在单独工作或在一个小小组中工作的研究人员有更多的论文(因此也有更高的引用和$h$索引)。因此,在分析作者的研究价值时,仅仅考虑发表论文的集体影响是不够的,还需要量化他/她在影响中的份额。对于这种量化,在这里我提出了$I$指数,它被定义为作者的百分比份额,他/她的论文吸引了总的引用。有人认为,这$I$指数并不直接依赖于大多数的主观问题,如作者的影响力,从属关系,资历或职业生涯中断。中心极限定理的一个简单应用表明,在一篇论文的合著者之间信用的等分布方案将给我们$h$-指数的最可能值(具有随$h$-指数增加而减小的相关小标准差)。我表明,总引文($N_c$),$h$-指数和$I$-指数是三个独立的参数(在其范围内),他们一起给一个作者的整体研究表现的全面的想法。

英文摘要:

A researcher collaborating with many groups will normally have more papers (and thus higher citations and $h$-index) than a researcher spending all his/her time working alone or in a small group. While analyzing an author's research merit, it is therefore not enough to consider only the collective impact of the published papers, it is also necessary to quantify his/her share in the impact. For this quantification, here I propose the $I$-index which is defined as an author's percentage share in the total citations that his/her papers have attracted. It is argued that this $I$-index does not directly depend on the most of the subjective issues like an author's influence, affiliation, seniority or career break. A simple application of the Central Limit Theorem shows that, the scheme of equidistribution of credit among the coauthors of a paper will give us the most probable value of the $I$-index (with an associated small standard deviation which decreases with increasing $h$-index). I show that the total citations ($N_c$), the $h$-index and the $I$-index are three independent parameters (within their bounds), and together they give a comprehensive idea of an author's overall research performance.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑