arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1506.07928gr-qcphysics.hist-ph
收藏

我们有时间是因为我们永远不会知道

We have time because we shall never know

Reza Tavakol, Edward Anderson

摘要:

我们反对目前关于时间不存在的建议。我们指出,大量的这些建议依赖于,至少是含蓄地,在“封闭”(或“部分封闭”)的物理定律的假设。也就是说,假设今天所知的物理定律要么是完备的(因此是封闭的),要么具有一个假设的未来“完备”理论所必须具有的特征(因此是部分封闭的)。由于物理定律封闭的假设永远无法在操作上得到验证,因此它不能被用来支持时间不存在的主张。一些反对时间的方法在整个宇宙的初级层次上是“永恒的”。在这些方法中,时间是次要的,主要是从“时间从变化中抽象出来”的意义上说。另一方面,也有其他方法完全否认时间的存在。我们认为,这种类型的形而上学的论点-类似于那些基于关闭-通过隐含地暗示历史的缺席,是其性质循环。

英文摘要:

We argue against current proposals concerning the non-existence of time. We point out that a large number of these proposals rely, at least implicitly, on the assumption of `closure' (or `partial closure') of the laws of Physics. I.e. the assumption that laws of Physics as they are known today are either complete (and hence closed) or that they possess features that a hypothetical future `complete' theory must share (and hence are partially closed). Given that the assumption of closure of laws of Physics can never be verified operationally, it cannot justifiably be used to support the claim for non-existence of time. Some approaches against time are `timeless' at the primary level for the universe as a whole. In these approaches time arises at a secondary level, mostly in the sense of `time being abstracted from change'. On the other hand, there are other approaches that deny the existence of time altogether. We argue that metaphysical arguments of this type - similar to those based on closure - by implicitly implying the absence of history, are by their nature circular.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑