太阳系的动力稳定性:系综积分的统计不确定结果
Dynamic stability of the Solar System: Statistically inconclusive results from ensemble integrations
摘要:
由于太阳系的混沌性质,它的长期稳定性问题只能在统计意义上回答,例如,基于附近轨道的数值系综积分。内行星的不稳定性,导致近距离接触和/或碰撞,可以通过水星离心率的大幅增加来启动,目前假设的可能性为~ 1%。然而,目前对这个数字的鲁棒性知之甚少。在这里,我报告的系综积分的完整方程的运动的八大行星和冥王星超过5 Gyr,包括贡献,从广义相对论。结果表明,不同的数值算法导致统计上不同的结果为水星的偏心率(eM)的演变。例如,从目前的初始条件(eM ~= 0.21)开始,水星的最大偏心率达到超过5 Gyr平均显着更高的辛系综积分使用日心比雅可比坐标和更严格的误差控制。相比之下,从未来可能的配置(eM ~= 0.53)开始,水星在随后的5亿年中达到的最大离心率平均而言明显低于雅可比坐标。例如,eM在5亿年内增加超过0.53的概率是>90%(雅可比),而日心说只有40-55%。这就造成了一个两难的局面,因为真实系统的物理演化--及其概率行为--不能依赖于用来描述它的坐标系或数值算法。对数值算法的一些测试表明,使用日心坐标的辛积分器低估了水星轨道在高初始eM时不稳定的几率。
英文摘要:
Due to the chaotic nature of the Solar System, the question of its long-term stability can only be answered in a statistical sense, for instance, based on numerical ensemble integrations of nearby orbits. Destabilization of the inner planets, leading to close encounters and/or collisions can be initiated through a large increase in Mercury's eccentricity, with a currently assumed likelihood of ~1%. However, little is known at present about the robustness of this number. Here I report ensemble integrations of the full equations of motion of the eight planets and Pluto over 5 Gyr, including contributions from general relativity. The results show that different numerical algorithms lead to statistically different results for the evolution of Mercury's eccentricity (eM). For instance, starting at present initial conditions (eM ~= 0.21), Mercury's maximum eccentricity achieved over 5 Gyr is on average significantly higher in symplectic ensemble integrations using heliocentricthan Jacobi coordinates and stricter error control. In contrast, starting at a possible future configuration (eM ~= 0.53), Mercury's maximum eccentricity achieved over the subsequent 500 Myr is on average significantly lower using heliocentric than Jacobi coordinates. For example, the probability for eM to increase beyond 0.53 over 500 Myr is >90% (Jacobi) vs. only 40-55% (heliocentric). This poses a dilemma as the physical evolution of the real system - and its probabilistic behavior - cannot depend on the coordinate system or numerical algorithm chosen to describe it. Some tests of the numerical algorithms suggest that symplectic integrators using heliocentric coordinates underestimate the odds for destabilization of Mercury's orbit at high initial eM.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。