arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1506.07447stat.ME
收藏

统计欺诈检测:对“科学诚信研究中ANOVA回归结果的证据价值”(Klaassen,2015)的评论

Fraud detection with statistics: A comment on "Evidential Value in ANOVA-Regression Results in Scientific Integrity Studies" (Klaassen, 2015)

Hannes Matuschek

摘要:

Klaassen在(Klaassen 2015)中提出了一种检测数据操纵的方法,给出了单因素ANOVA设计单元格的平均值和标准差。这篇评论批判性地评论了这种方法。此外,受此分析的启发,一种替代的方法来测试样本相关性在几个实验。结果与匿名举报人报告的初步分析非常一致。重要的是,统计量需要几个类似的实验;基于单个实验的3个样本均值之间的相关性检验必须被认为是不可靠的。

英文摘要:

Klaassen in (Klaassen 2015) proposed a method for the detection of data manipulation given the means and standard deviations for the cells of a oneway ANOVA design. This comment critically reviews this method. In addition, inspired by this analysis, an alternative approach to test sample correlations over several experiments is derived. The results are in close agreement with the initial analysis reported by an anonymous whistlelblower. Importantly, the statistic requires several similar experiments; a test for correlations between 3 sample means based on a single experiment must be considered as unreliable.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑