arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1506.06405stat.ME
收藏

实值预测的组合与优化

Combining and Extremizing Real-Valued Forecasts

Ville Satopää, Lyle Ungar

摘要:

加权平均是迄今为止最流行的方法,可以将对某些未来结果的多种预测结合起来。本文表明,无论是概率或实值预测,一个非平凡的加权平均不同的预测总是次优的。更具体地说,它与任何关于未来结果的信息集都不一致,即使个别预测是一致的。此外,加权平均的表现不像是从预测者那里收集信息,因此需要进行极值化,也就是说,系统地从边际平均值转换出来。本文提出了一种改进实值预测加权平均的线性极值化方法。由此产生的加权平均值的更极端的版本表现出许多最优聚合的属性。这两个和次优的加权平均值说明了简单的例子,涉及合成和现实世界的数据。

英文摘要:

The weighted average is by far the most popular approach to combining multiple forecasts of some future outcome. This paper shows that both for probability or real-valued forecasts, a non-trivial weighted average of different forecasts is always sub-optimal. More specifically, it is not consistent with any set of information about the future outcome even if the individual forecasts are. Furthermore, weighted averaging does not behave as if it collects information from the forecasters and hence needs to be extremized, that is, systematically transformed away from the marginal mean. This paper proposes a linear extremization technique for improving the weighted average of real-valued forecasts. The resulting more extreme version of the weighted average exhibits many properties of optimal aggregation. Both this and the sub-optimality of the weighted average are illustrated with simple examples involving synthetic and real-world data.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑