arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1506.03973physics.soc-phcs.GTq-bio.PE
收藏

说善意的谎言是亲社会偏好的信号吗?

Does telling white lies signal pro-social preferences?

Laura Biziou-van-Pol, Jana Haenen, Arianna Novaro, Andrés Occhipinti Liberman, Valerio Capraro

摘要:

撒一个善意的谎言(white lie)一个有利于另一个人的谎言)在两个相反的道德要求之间产生道德冲突,一个要求总是说实话,另一个要求帮助他人。在这里,我们研究人们如何解决这种道德冲突。说一个善意的谎言意味着一个人的亲社会倾向?为了回答这个问题,我们进行了一个两阶段的2x2实验。在第一阶段,我们使用欺骗游戏来测量对说帕累托善意谎言的厌恶(即,一个帮助说谎者和听者的谎言),以及厌恶讲利他主义的善意谎言(即,一个以说谎者为代价帮助听者的谎言)。在第二阶段,我们测量利他主义倾向使用独裁者游戏和合作倾向使用囚徒困境。我们发现了三个主要结果:(1)利他主义和合作都与厌恶说帕累托善意谎言呈正相关;(2)利他主义和合作都与厌恶说利他善意谎言呈负相关;(3)男性比女性更可能说利他善意谎言,但不可能说帕累托善意谎言。我们的研究结果揭示了亲社会和说真话之间的道德冲突。特别是,第一个发现表明,相当一部分人对正确的事情是什么有非分配的概念:不管他们的经济后果如何,他们说实话,他们合作,他们分享他们的钱。

英文摘要:

The opportunity to tell a white lie (i.e., a lie that benefits another person) generates a moral conflict between two opposite moral dictates, one pushing towards telling always the truth and the other pushing towards helping others. Here we study how people resolve this moral conflict. What does telling a white lie signal about a person's pro-social tendencies? To answer this question, we conducted a two-stage 2x2 experiment. In the first stage, we used a Deception Game to measure aversion to telling a Pareto white lie (i.e., a lie that helps both the liar and the listener), and aversion to telling an altruistic white lie (i.e., a lie that helps the listener at the expense of the liar). In the second stage we measured altruistic tendencies using a Dictator Game and cooperative tendencies using a Prisoner's dilemma. We found three major results: (i) both altruism and cooperation are positively correlated with aversion to telling a Pareto white lie; (ii) both altruism and cooperation are negatively correlated with aversion to telling an altruistic white lie; (iii) men are more likely than women to tell an altruistic white lie, but not to tell a Pareto white lie. Our results shed light on the moral conflit between pro-sociality and truth-telling. In particular, the first finding suggests that a significant proportion of people have non-distributional notions of what the right thing to do is: irrespective of their economic consequences, they tell the truth, they cooperate, they share their money.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑