arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1503.03666stat.MEstat.AP
收藏

暴力再犯风险的统计评估述评

A Commentary on Statistical Assessment of Violence Recidivism Risk

Peter B. Imrey, A. Philip Dawid

摘要:

关于大群体的数据的日益集成和可用性已经伴随着银行、保险、营销、医学和其他领域中的统计和其他算法预测工具的激增(参见例如,Steyerberg(2009年a;b))。当这些工具被引入传统上依赖于个体临床评估的领域时,可能会引起争议。对暴力再犯风险的“精算”评估引起了这样的争议,即,被发现犯下暴力行为的人在特定时期内再次犯下暴力行为的可能性。最近,Hart et al.(2007 a)和这些作者随后在几个著名期刊上发表的论文声称,对这些风险的统计评估本质上太不精确,以至于没有用处,使用的论点似乎适用于相当广泛的统计风险预测。本评论从技术统计的角度来考察这些论点,发现它们在许多细节上存在严重错误。他们不应在暴力惯犯风险评估的理性讨论中发挥作用。

英文摘要:

Increasing integration and availability of data on large groups of persons has been accompanied by proliferation of statistical and other algorithmic prediction tools in banking, insurance, marketiNg, medicine, and other FIelds (see e.g., Steyerberg (2009a;b)). Controversy may ensue when such tools are introduced to fields traditionally reliant on individual clinical evaluations. Such controversy has arisen about "actuarial" assessments of violence recidivism risk, i.e., the probability that someone found to have committed a violent act will commit another during a specified period. Recently Hart et al. (2007a) and subsequent papers from these authors in several reputable journals have claimed to demonstrate that statistical assessments of such risks are inherently too imprecise to be useful, using arguments that would seem to apply to statistical risk prediction quite broadly. This commentary examines these arguments from a technical statistical perspective, and finds them seriously mistaken in many particulars. They should play no role in reasoned discussions of violence recidivism risk assessment.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑