arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1501.04415stat.APq-bio.QM
收藏

荟萃分析方法中截断p值的插补及其在基因组学中的应用

Imputation of truncated p-values for meta-analysis methods and its genomic application

Shaowu Tang, Ying Ding, Etienne Sibille, Jeffrey S. Mogil, William R. Lariviere, George C. Tseng

摘要:

在过去的十年中,微阵列分析同时监测数千个基因的表达活动已经成为生物医学研究的常规。大量的表达谱被生成并存储在公共领域,通过荟萃分析进行信息整合以检测差异表达(DE)基因已经变得流行,以获得增加的统计功效和验证的发现。聚集转换后的$p$值证据的方法已被广泛应用于基因组环境中,其中Fisher和Stouffer方法是最流行的方法。在实践中,DE证据的原始数据和$p$ -值通常在要合并的基因组研究中不可用。相反,仅检测到的DE基因在特定$p$值阈值(例如,具有$p$ -值${}<0.001$的DE基因)在期刊出版物中报道。截断的$p$ -值信息使得上述荟萃分析方法不适用,研究者被迫应用效率较低的投票计数方法或天真地放弃信息不完整的研究。本文的目的是开发有效的荟萃分析方法,这种情况下,部分删失的$p$值。我们开发并比较了三种插补方法-平均插补,单随机插补和多重插补-为一般类的证据聚合方法,其中费舍尔和Stouffer的方法是特殊的例子。每种方法的零分布进行了分析推导,并建立了后续的推理和基因组分析框架。进行模拟以研究(相关的)基因表达数据的第一类错误、功效和错误发现率(FDR)的控制。所提出的方法被应用到几个基因组应用在结直肠癌,疼痛和液体关联分析的抑郁症(MDD)。结果表明,插补方法优于现有的朴素方法。平均插补和多重插补方法表现最好,建议用于未来的应用。

英文摘要:

Microarray analysis to monitor expression activities in thousands of genes simultaneously has become routine in biomedical research during the past decade. A tremendous amount of expression profiles are generated and stored in the public domain and information integration by meta-analysis to detect differentially expressed (DE) genes has become popular to obtain increased statistical power and validated findings. Methods that aggregate transformed $p$-value evidence have been widely used in genomic settings, among which Fisher's and Stouffer's methods are the most popular ones. In practice, raw data and $p$-values of DE evidence are often not available in genomic studies that are to be combined. Instead, only the detected DE gene lists under a certain $p$-value threshold (e.g., DE genes with $p$-value${}<0.001$) are reported in journal publications. The truncated $p$-value information makes the aforementioned meta-analysis methods inapplicable and researchers are forced to apply a less efficient vote counting method or naïvely drop the studies with incomplete information. The purpose of this paper is to develop effective meta-analysis methods for such situations with partially censored $p$-values. We developed and compared three imputation methods - mean imputation, single random imputation and multiple imputation - for a general class of evidence aggregation methods of which Fisher's and Stouffer's methods are special examples. The null distribution of each method was analytically derived and subsequent inference and genomic analysis frameworks were established. Simulations were performed to investigate the type I error, power and the control of false discovery rate (FDR) for (correlated) gene expression data. The proposed methods were applied to several genomic applications in colorectal cancer, pain and liquid association analysis of major depressive disorder (MDD). The results showed that imputation methods outperformed existing naïve approaches. Mean imputation and multiple imputation methods performed the best and are recommended for future applications.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑