对数律是李群不变性分析的第一原理结果吗?
Is the log-law a first principle result from Lie-group invariance analysis?
摘要:
湍流理论中李群的不变性方法被认为是产生统计标度律的第一原理方法。这一评论的目的是表明,这一期望迄今尚未实现。特别是对于有壁面的湍流,从我们将在这里提出的事实来看,成功的前景是不乐观的。虽然李群的不变性方法能够产生壁界湍流的统计标度律,例如对数律,但这些不变结果不仅不能满足第一原理结果的基本要求,而且具有很强的误导性。原因不是对数律本身的函数结构是误导的,而是它的基于不变李群的推导产生了这个函数是误导的。通过回顾Oberlack(2001)的研究,我们将证明所有李群生成的标度律都不能作为第一原理解。相反,一个严格的推导揭示了完整的任意性,而不是唯一性不变的湍流标度律的建设。这里需要注意的是,Oberlack(2001)中获得的关键结果是基于几个技术错误,所有这些错误都将被揭示,讨论和纠正。我们之所以把重点放在Oberlack(2001)上,是因为它仍然是李群方法应用于湍流理论的核心研究和中心参考点。因此,有必要对这项研究进行正确的阐述。尽管如此,即使李群方法在其全部范围内得到正确的应用和解释,在湍流理论中,这种方法仍然存在很强的自然局限性,正如最后将要讨论的那样,这些局限性构成了实现重大突破的不可逾越的障碍。
英文摘要:
The invariance method of Lie-groups in the theory of turbulence carries the high expectation of being a first principle method for generating statistical scaling laws. The purpose of this comment is to show that this expectation has not been met so far. In particular for wall-bounded turbulent flows, the prospects for success are not promising in view of the facts we will present herein. Although the invariance method of Lie-groups is able to generate statistical scaling laws for wall-bounded turbulent flows, like the log-law for example, these invariant results yet not only fail to fulfil the basic requirements for a first principle result, but also are strongly misleading. The reason is that not the functional structure of the log-law itself is misleading, but that its invariant Lie-group based derivation yielding this function is what is misleading. By revisiting the study of Oberlack (2001) we will demonstrate that all Lie-group generated scaling laws derived therein do not convince as first principle solutions. Instead, a rigorous derivation reveals complete arbitrariness rather than uniqueness in the construction of invariant turbulent scaling laws. Important to note here is that the key results obtained in Oberlack (2001) are based on several technical errors, which all will be revealed, discussed and corrected. The reason and motivation why we put our focus solely on Oberlack (2001) is that it still marks the core study and central reference point when applying the method of Lie-groups to turbulence theory. Hence it is necessary to shed the correct light onto that study. Nevertheless, even if the method of Lie-groups in its full extent is applied and interpreted correctly, strong natural limits of this method within the theory of turbulence exist, which, as will be finally discussed, constitute insurmountable obstacles in the progress of achieving a significant breakthrough.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。