不完全提取数据的优势比Meta分析
Meta-Analysis of Odds Ratios With Incomplete Extracted Data
摘要:
一项典型的比值比随机效应荟萃分析假设治疗组和对照组中事件数量呈二项分布,并要求从已发表的论文中提取死亡比例。由于失访,这些数据通常无法在出版物中获得。当Kaplan Meier生存图可用时,通常的做法是从图中手动测量所需的信息并推断生存概率,然后推断死亡人数的最佳猜测。目前的模型没有考虑到这些猜测带来的不确定性。这种天真的方法会导致过于确定的结果和可能不准确的结论。我们提出了不确定阅读估计事件模型,使用出版物中可供提取的数据分别构建每项研究对荟萃分析的贡献。我们使用真实和模拟数据来说明我们的方法。基于观察到的死亡人数的荟萃分析会导致有偏估计,而我们提出的模型不会。我们的研究结果显示,与假设理想提取数据的朴素荟萃分析相比,对数比值的标准差增加,相当于在我们的示例中总体样本量减少了43%。
英文摘要:
A typical random effects meta-analysis of odds-ratios assumes binomially distributed numbers of events in a treatment and control group and requires the proportion of deaths to be extracted from published papers. This data is often not available in the publications due to loss to follow-up. When the Kaplan Meier survival plot is available, it is common practice to manually measure the needed information from the plot and infer the probability of survival and then to infer a best-guess of the number of deaths. Uncertainty introduced from theses guesses is not accounted for in current models. This naive approach leads to over-certain results and potentially inaccurate conclusions. We propose the Uncertain Reading-Estimated Events model to construct each study's contribution to the meta-analysis separately using the data available for extraction in the publications. We use real and simulated data to illustrate our methods. Meta-analysis based on the observed number of deaths lead to biased estimates while our proposed model does not. Our results show increases in the standard deviation of the log-odds as compared to a naive meta-analysis that assumes ideal extracted data, equivalent to a reduction of the overall sample size of 43% in our example.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。