判断矩阵的几何平均法:误差公式
Geometric mean method for judgement matrices: Formulas for errors
摘要:
几何平均方法(GMM)和特征向量方法(EM)是在决策过程中从成对比较矩阵中获得信息的公知方法。然而,这些方法的原始算法是逻辑上不完整的,有显着的缺点:他们的实际数值误差是未知的,他们的可靠性是怀疑不同的秩反转现象,包括GMM-EM的。最近(Tomashevskii 2015:Eur J Oper Res 240:774-780),发现了EM的实际数值误差,并且表明所有EM秩反转现象具有相同的原因,并且当考虑误差时被消除。本文对GMM也采用了类似的方法:将GMM与一些标准的测量过程联系起来,从测量理论的角度对这一过程进行分析,找出GMM的实际误差。我们表明,GMM和GMM-EM秩反转现象被消除时,GMM和EM误差被考虑。GMM决策支持工具具有标准测量工具的所有组件,由成对比较作为初始测量程序、GMM作为数据处理器以及所获得的GMM误差公式作为误差指标组成。该工具类似于上述论文前面提到的EM决策支持工具。它示出的EM和GMM版本的工具是同样适合于测量和排名任何可比的元素与积极的数值。我们还分析了几何一致性指数通常用于在原来的GMM来衡量的不一致性和接受或拒绝不一致的成对比较矩阵,并表明,该指数是不是一个可接受的GMM错误指标。
英文摘要:
The geometric mean method (GMM) and the eigenvector method (EM) are well-known approaches to deriving information from pairwise comparison matrices in decision making processes. However, the original algorithms of these methods are logically incomplete and have significant drawbacks: their actual numerical errors are unknown and their reliability is doubted by different rank reversal phenomena including the GMM-EM ones. Recently (Tomashevskii 2015: Eur J Oper Res 240:774-780), the actual numerical errors were found for EM, and it was shown that all EM rank reversal phenomena have the same cause and are eliminated when the errors are taken into account. In this paper the similar ap-proach is used for GMM: we associate GMM with some standard measuring procedure, ana-lyze this procedure from the viewpoint of measurement theory, and find the actual GMM errors. We show that the GMM and the GMM-EM rank reversal phenomena are eliminated when the GMM and the EM errors are taken into account. The GMM decision support tool, which has all components of a standard measuring tool, is composed of pairwise comparisons as an initial measuring procedure, GMM as a data processor, and the obtained formulas for GMM errors as an error indicator. This tool is analogous to the EM decision support tool received earlier in the above paper. It is shown that the EM and the GMM versions of the tool are equally suitable to measure and rank any comparable elements with positive numerical values. We also analyze the Geometric Consistency Index usually used in the original GMM to measure of the inconsistency and to accept or reject an inconsistent pairwise comparison matrix, and show that this index is not an acceptable GMM error indicator.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。