arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1409.4700q-bio.NCq-bio.PE
收藏

索尔对动物创新进化的解释能解释人类创新吗?

Can Sol's Explanation for the Evolution of Animal Innovation Account for Human Innovation?

Liane Gabora, Apara Ranjan

摘要:

索尔认为,创新倾向不是一个专门的适应有针对性的选择,但一个exaptation的情况下,因为选择不能只遇到一次的情况下。在外适应中,一个最初进化来解决一个问题的特征被增选来解决一个新问题;因此,所讨论的特征必须是解决新问题的必要和充分条件。索尔声称,动物的创新需要反复试验,而动物的创新则需要持久性和喜新性等特征。我们认为,这种解释并不适用于人类的创新,这涉及到策略,逻辑,直觉和洞察力,并需要进化的特征,而不是作为其他功能的副产品,而是为了对环境变化本身做出适应性反应。我们指出一个基于代理的模型,表明两个这样的建议的特点的可行性:(1)链接,从简单的构建复杂的思想的能力,和(2)上下文焦点,在收敛和发散的思维模式之间转换的能力。我们同意,在某种意义上,创新是一种适应-它发生在现有的物体或行为适应新的需要或口味时-并指生物和文化提升的数学模型。我们的结论是,通过比较和对比动物和人类的创新,我们可以获得很多。

英文摘要:

Sol argues that innovation propensity is not a specialized adaptation resulting from targeted selection but an instance of exaptation because selection cannot act on situations that are only encountered once. In exaptation, a trait that originally evolved to solve one problem is co-opted to solve a new problem; thus the trait or traits in question must be necessary and sufficient to solve the new problem. Sol claims that traits such as persistence and neophilia, are necessary and sufficient for animal innovation, which is a matter of trial and error. We suggest that this explanation does not extend to human innovation, which involves strategy, logic, intuition, and insight, and requires traits that evolved, not as a byproduct of some other function, but for the purpose of coming up with adaptive responses to environmental variability itself. We point to an agent based model that indicates the feasibility of two such proposed traits: (1) chaining, the ability to construct complex thoughts from simple ones, and (2) contextual focus, the ability to shift between convergent and divergent modes of thought. We agree that there is a sense in which innovation is exaptation--it occurs when an existing object or behaviour is adapted to new needs or tastes--and refer to a mathematical model of biological and cultural exaltation. We conclude that much is gained by comparing and contrasting animal and human innovation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑