arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1408.1930math.HO
收藏

Pierre van Hiele、David Tall和Hans Freudenthal:让事实正确

Pierre van Hiele, David Tall and Hans Freudenthal: Getting the facts right

Thomas Colignatus

摘要:

皮埃尔·范·希勒(Pierre van Hiele,1909-2010)在1957年和后来多次提出,范·希勒的洞察力水平可以广泛应用于更多学科和不同的数学科目。David Tall(2013)认为Van Hiele只看到了几何的应用。Tall声称,只有他自己现在扩展到更广泛的应用。如果事实是正确的,可以看出,Tall误解了Van Hiele(2002)。它仍然是重要的是,高支持广泛应用范希勒的理论。显然,高不知道弗赖登塔尔也声称这一点。自1957年以来,似乎普遍缺乏对Van Hiele - Freudenthal组合的了解。汉斯弗赖登塔尔(1905年至1990年)还建议,范希勒只看到应用几何,只有他,弗赖登塔尔,看到了一般的应用。弗赖登塔尔采用了范·希勒的各种概念,歪曲了这些概念,给自己取了新的名字,并开始提到这一点,而不是范·希勒。这种错误的陈述可以解释为什么Tall没有承认Van Hiele的理论。弗赖登塔尔错误地把范·希勒的具体与抽象的区别,当成了现实与模型的区别(应用数学)。弗赖登塔尔的“现实数学教育”(RME)的误解部分是不工作的,工作的一部分,主要是从范希勒。这种对范·希勒的普遍缺乏理解,部分地解释了数学教育和数学研究的现状。另一个因素是,像弗赖登塔尔和塔尔这样的数学家接受的是抽象训练,对数学教育的原理了解较少。

英文摘要:

Pierre van Hiele (1909-2010) suggested, both in 1957 and later repeatedly, wide application for the Van Hiele levels in insight, both for more disciplines and for different subjects in mathematics. David Tall (2013) suggests that Van Hiele only saw application to geometry. Tall claims that only he himself now extends to wider application. Getting the facts right, it can be observed that Tall misread Van Hiele (2002). It remains important that Tall supports the wide application of Van Hiele's theory. Tall apparently didn't know that Freudenthal claimed it too. There appears to exist a general lack of understanding of the Van Hiele - Freudenthal combination since 1957. Hans Freudenthal (1905-1990) also suggested that Van Hiele only saw application to geometry, and that only he, Freudenthal, saw the general application. Freudenthal adopted various notions from Van Hiele, misrepresented those, gave those new names of himself, and started referring to this instead of to Van Hiele. The misrepresentation may clarify why Tall didn't recognise Van Hiele's theory. Freudenthal mistook Van Hiele's distinction of concrete versus abstract for the distinction of reality versus model (applied mathematics). Freudenthal's misconception of "realistic mathematics education" (RME) partly doesn't work and the part that works was mostly taken from Van Hiele. This common lack of understanding of Van Hiele partly explains the situation in the education in mathematics and the research on this. Another factor is that mathematicians like Freudenthal and Tall are trained for abstraction and have less understanding of the empirics of mathematics education.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑