arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1407.3682q-bio.PEcs.DL
收藏

当数据共享接近100%时:什么古代人类DNA研究可以教开放科学运动

When data sharing gets close to 100%: what ancient human DNA studies can teach the Open Science movement

Paolo Anagnostou, Marco Capocasa, Nicola Milia, Emanuele Sanna, Daniela Luzi, Giovanni Destro Bisol

摘要:

该研究分析了1988年至2013年期间发表的162篇关于人类古代DNA的论文中有关线粒体,Y染色体和常染色体多态性的数据共享率和方式。在大多数情况下,数据的提供方式使其审查和再利用成为可能。估计的共享率与总体水平相差不远(97.6% +/- 2.1%),并且远高于其他遗传研究领域(进化遗传学、医学遗传学和法医遗传学)的观察结果。一项基于数据库的调查表明,作者认识到公开和透明对科学进步的重要性,这是实现如此高的共享率的一个基本因素。大多数数据通过正文提供,但随着完整线粒体和下一代测序方法的应用,初级数据库的使用增加。我们的研究突出了三个重要方面。首先,我们提供的证据表明,研究人员的动机是必要的利益相关者的政策和规范,以实现非常高的共享率。其次,认真分析提供数据的方式是最大限度地提高数据的可查找性、可获取性、可使用性和保存性的重要的第一步。第三,也是最后一点,人类古代DNA研究的案例展示了开放科学如何促进科学进步,表明即使在存在复杂的实验挑战的情况下,开放和透明也有助于建立严格和可靠的科学实践。

英文摘要:

This study analyzes rates and ways of data sharing regarding mitochondrial, Y chromosomal and autosomal polymorphisms in a total of 162 papers on human ancient DNA published between 1988 and 2013. For the most part, data are available in such a way as to make their scrutiny and reuse possible. The estimated sharing rate is not far from totality (97.6% +/- 2.1%) and substantially higher than observed in other fields of genetic research (Evolutionary, Medical and Forensic Genetics). A questionnaire-based survey suggests that the authors awareness of the importance of openness and transparency for scientific progress is a fundamental factor for the achievement of such a high sharing rate. Most data were made available through body text, but the use of primary databases increased with the application of complete mitochondrial and next generation sequencing methods. Our study highlights three important aspects. First, we provide evidence that researchers motivations are as necessary as stakeholders policies and norms to achieve very high sharing rates. Second, careful analyses of the ways in which data are made available are an important first step to maximize data findability, accessibility, useability and preservation. Third and finally, the case of human ancient DNA studies demonstrates how Open Science can foster scientific advancements, showing that openness and transparency can help build rigorous and reliable scientific practices even in the presence of complex experimental challenges.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑