arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1405.3713cs.AI
收藏

具有副作用的语境溯因推理

Contextual Abductive Reasoning with Side-Effects

International Center for Computational Logic TU Dresden(德累斯顿工业大学国际计算逻辑中心)

Luís Moniz Pereira, Emmanuelle-Anna Dietz, Steffen Hölldobler

摘要:

信念偏差效应是一种现象,当我们认为我们根据我们的推理来判断一个论点时,但实际上受到我们的信念和先验知识的影响。Evans、Barston和Pollard进行了一个心理学的三段论推理任务来证明这种效应。参与者被问到他们是否会接受或拒绝一个给定的三段论。我们讨论一个具体的情况下,这是通常被认为是可信的,但实际上是不符合逻辑的。通过引入异常、溯因和背景知识,我们在弱完备语义下充分地建模了这种情况。我们的形式化揭示了新的问题可能的扩展溯因推理。例如,观察及其解释可能包括一些相关的先前溯因上下文信息,这些信息涉及一些副作用或导致可解释或可反驳的副作用。一个较弱的概念表明支持一些相关的后果由一个先前的溯因上下文。另一个定义描述了联合支持的相关后果,它抓住了两个观察结果包含相互支持的副作用的想法。本文以跑步心理学应用为例,引入了各种新的一般溯因语境定义,并首次给出了陈述性语义,具有更广泛的应用范围。Pereira和Pinto提出的检查点概念,允许我们在语法上表达这些定义,并将它们插入操作语义。

英文摘要:

The belief bias effect is a phenomenon which occurs when we think that we judge an argument based on our reasoning, but are actually influenced by our beliefs and prior knowledge. Evans, Barston and Pollard carried out a psychological syllogistic reasoning task to prove this effect. Participants were asked whether they would accept or reject a given syllogism. We discuss one specific case which is commonly assumed to be believable but which is actually not logically valid. By introducing abnormalities, abduction and background knowledge, we adequately model this case under the weak completion semantics. Our formalization reveals new questions about possible extensions in abductive reasoning. For instance, observations and their explanations might include some relevant prior abductive contextual information concerning some side-effect or leading to a contestable or refutable side-effect. A weaker notion indicates the support of some relevant consequences by a prior abductive context. Yet another definition describes jointly supported relevant consequences, which captures the idea of two observations containing mutually supportive side-effects. Though motivated with and exemplified by the running psychology application, the various new general abductive context definitions are introduced here and given a declarative semantics for the first time, and have a much wider scope of application. Inspection points, a concept introduced by Pereira and Pinto, allows us to express these definitions syntactically and intertwine them into an operational semantics.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑