arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1405.0207physics.soc-ph
收藏

对“评”一个超越齐普夫定律的标度定律及其与堆定律的关系“一文的答复

Reply to "Comment on 'A Scaling law beyond Zipf's law and its relation to Heaps' law'"

Francesc Font-Clos, Álvaro Corral

摘要:

在[arXiv:1404.1461]中,Yan和Minnnesian认为[New J. Phys. 15 093033,arXiv:1303.0705]中提出的词频分布的文本长度依赖性的标度律是“根本不正确的”和“根本不可能的”。在本说明中,我们认为这种说法显然是不合理的,标度定律对于绝对频率大于10的情况显然是有效的。此外,我们还证明了Yan和Minnnnel [arXiv:1404.1461]提供的反例非常准确地满足了我们的标度假设,与Yan和Minnel的批评不一致,并支持我们的方法。

英文摘要:

In [arXiv:1404.1461], Yan and Minnhagen argue that the scaling law for the text-length dependence of word-frequency distributions proposed in [New J. Phys. 15 093033, arXiv:1303.0705] is "fundamentally incorrect" and "fundamentally impossible". In this note, we reason that such claims are clearly unjustified, with the scaling law being clearly valid for absolute frequencies greater than about 10. Further, we show that the very counter-example provided by Yan and Minnhagen [arXiv:1404.1461] fulfils our scaling hypothesis with excellent accuracy, at odds with Yan and Minnhagen's criticisms, and supporting our approach.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑