作为社会选择的热力学假设:蛋白质折叠的一个不可能定理
Thermodynamic Hypothesis as Social Choice: An Impossibility Theorem for Protein Folding
摘要:
蛋白质折叠是关于蛋白质三级结构背后的原因和机制。Anfinsen的热力学假说假定了一个通用能量函数(UEF),它表征了蛋白质的三级结构,并根据其氨基酸序列一致地定义。我们考虑在PDB(蛋白质数据库)中检查多个蛋白质结构描述符的方法,并推断个体偏好,偏好每个氨基酸相互作用的特定类别的偏好,然后将这些个体偏好聚合成全局偏好。这个两步过程将理想地暴露UEF本身中氨基酸相互作用类别的内在偏差。直觉是,UEF中的任何内在偏差都以与其特定氨基酸序列、大小和折叠一致的特定方式在每种蛋白质中表达(与Anfinsen的热力学假设一致),使得1步整体聚集不太理想。我们的目的是说明如何从投票理论的一些不可能的结果将适用于这种情况下,可能适用于其他蛋白质折叠的问题。我们认为投票理论的概念和结果,并揭示上述方法的方法上的困难。通过我们的观察,我们打算强调经济学家已经暴露的关键理论障碍如何与蛋白质折叠相关问题的新方法,新算法的开发相关。
英文摘要:
Protein Folding is concerned with the reasons and mechanism behind a protein's tertiary structure. The thermodynamic hypothesis of Anfinsen postulates an universal energy function (UEF) characterizing the tertiary structure, defined consistently across proteins, in terms of their aminoacid sequence. We consider the approach of examining multiple protein structure descriptors in the PDB (Protein Data Bank), and infer individual preferences, biases favoring particular classes of aminoacid interactions in each of them, later aggregating these individual preferences into a global preference. This 2-step process would ideally expose intrinsic biases on classes of aminoacid interactions in the UEF itself. The intuition is that any intrinsic biases in the UEF are expressed within each protein in a specific manner consistent with its specific aminoacid sequence, size, and fold (consistently with Anfinsen's thermodynamic hypothesis), making a 1-step, holistic aggregation less desirable. Our intention is to illustrate how some impossibility results from voting theory would apply in this setting, being possibly applicable to other protein folding problems as well. We consider concepts and results from voting theory and unveil methodological difficulties for the approach mentioned above. With our observations, we intend to highlight how key theoretical barriers, already exposed by economists, can be relevant for the development of new methods, new algorithms, for problems related to protein folding.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。