维基百科合作的博弈分析
A Game Theoretic Analysis of Collaboration in Wikipedia
摘要:
同行生产项目,如维基百科或开源软件开发允许志愿者集体创造基于知识的产品。这些项目的包容性对确保可信度和打击破坏行为提出了困难的挑战。以前的研究在该地区处理同行生产的描述性方面,未能捕捉到的想法,而贡献者合作,他们也竞争的地位,在社区和强加自己的观点的产品。在本文中,我们调查在维基百科的贡献者追加和覆盖以前的贡献页面的协作创作。我们假设贡献者的目标是最大化内容部分的所有权,这样她拥有(或起源)的内容在页面的最新修订中幸存下来。我们模型的贡献者的互动,以增加他们的内容所有权作为一个非合作的游戏,玩家的效用与拥有的内容和成本是一个功能的努力花费。我们的研究结果捕捉了贡献者在同行生产项目中的互动的几个现实生活方面。我们表明,在纳什均衡有一个贡献和生存的贡献者内容所需的努力之间的反比关系。换句话说,大多数幸存下来的内容必然是由专家贡献的,他们比非专家花费的精力相对较少。对维基百科文章的实证分析为我们的模型预测提供了支持。研究和实践的影响进行了讨论的背景下,值得信赖的合作,以及破坏。
英文摘要:
Peer production projects such as Wikipedia or open-source software development allow volunteers to collectively create knowledge based products. The inclusive nature of such projects poses difficult challenges for ensuring trustworthiness and combating vandalism. Prior studies in the area deal with descriptive aspects of peer production, failing to capture the idea that while contributors collaborate, they also compete for status in the community and for imposing their views on the product. In this paper we investigate collaborative authoring in Wikipedia where contributors append and overwrite previous contributions to a page. We assume that a contributors goal is to maximize ownership of content sections such that content owned (or originated) by her survived the most recent revision of the page. We model contributors interactions to increase their content ownership as a noncooperative game where a players utility is associated with content owned and cost is a function of effort expended. Our results capture several real life aspects of contributors interactions within peer production projects. We show that at the Nash equilibrium there is an inverse relationship between the effort required to make a contribution and the survival of a contributors content. In other words majority of the content that survives is necessarily contributed by experts who expend relatively less effort than non experts. An empirical analysis of Wikipedia articles provides support for our models predictions. Implications for research and practice are discussed in the context of trustworthy collaboration as well as vandalism.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。