论具有积极和消极特征的决策的定性比较
On the Qualitative Comparison of Decisions Having Positive and Negative Features
摘要:
做决定往往是一个列举和比较正反两方面论据的问题。在这种情况下,决策的评价尺度应被视为两极,即应明确区分消极和积极的价值。例如,累积前景理论就是这样做的。然而,与后一种以真正的数值评估为前提的框架相反,人类代理人通常根据利弊的顺序排列来决定,并专注于最突出的论点。换句话说,决策过程是定性的,也是两极的。在这篇文章中,基于两极扩展的可能性理论,我们定义和公理化的特点定制的联合处理的积极和消极的参数在一个有序设置的决策规则。最简单的规则可以被看作是极大极小和极大极大准则对双极情形的扩展,因此具有较差的决定性。还提出了完善前者的更具决定性的规则。这些改进既符合效率原则,又符合数量级推理的精神,这在定性决策理论中占主导地位。最精细的决策规则使用leximin排名的优点和缺点,并计算参数的同等强度和取消利弊的想法。它被证明归结为一个特殊的情况下,累积前景理论,并subsidering采取最好的启发式研究的认知心理学家。
英文摘要:
Making a decision is often a matter of listing and comparing positive and negative arguments. In such cases, the evaluation scale for decisions should be considered bipolar, that is, negative and positive values should be explicitly distinguished. That is what is done, for example, in Cumulative Prospect Theory. However, contraryto the latter framework that presupposes genuine numerical assessments, human agents often decide on the basis of an ordinal ranking of the pros and the cons, and by focusing on the most salient arguments. In other terms, the decision process is qualitative as well as bipolar. In this article, based on a bipolar extension of possibility theory, we define and axiomatically characterize several decision rules tailored for the joint handling of positive and negative arguments in an ordinal setting. The simplest rules can be viewed as extensions of the maximin and maximax criteria to the bipolar case, and consequently suffer from poor decisive power. More decisive rules that refine the former are also proposed. These refinements agree both with principles of efficiency and with the spirit of order-of-magnitude reasoning, that prevails in qualitative decision theory. The most refined decision rule uses leximin rankings of the pros and the cons, and the ideas of counting arguments of equal strength and cancelling pros by cons. It is shown to come down to a special case of Cumulative Prospect Theory, and to subsume the Take the Best heuristic studied by cognitive psychologists.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。