arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1312.7576cond-mat.mtrl-scicond-mat.mes-hall
收藏

Cd3As2是中心对称的

Cd3As2 is Centrosymmetric

Mazhar N. Ali, Quinn Gibson, Sangjun Jeon, Brian B. Zhou, Ali Yazdani, R. J. Cava

摘要:

这是一份手稿的修订版,最初于2014年2月发布在这里。它已经被《无机化学》杂志接受,经过审查,其中包括两位晶体学家,他们确保所有的t都是交叉的,i是点状的。旧的工作(从1968年开始)说Cd 3As 2是非中心对称的是错误的,该研究的作者犯了一种错误,在20世纪80年代成为晶体学中臭名昭著的错误。由于20世纪80年代对中心对称性问题的审查越来越多,现在有更好的分析工具来完全解决这个问题,重要的是要理解不仅我们的晶体是中心对称的,甚至老人的晶体也是中心对称的(暗示每个人都是)。当年犯了这个错误并不可耻,那些作者也不会觉得现在的中心对称结果有争议;他们的论文在其他方面都很出色。本手稿描述了如何确定结构,示意性地解释了结构,基于正确的中心对称晶体结构计算了电子结构,并给出了应用于未来分析和建模的结构细节。

英文摘要:

This is a revised version of a manuscript that was originally posted here in February of 2014. It has been accepted at the journal Inorganic Chemistry after reviews that included those of two crystallographers who made sure all the t's were crossed and the i's were dotted. The old work (from 1968) that said that Cd3As2 was noncentrosymmetric was mistaken, with the authors of that study making a type of error that in the 1980s became infamous in crystallography. As a result of the increased scrutiny of the issue of centrosymmetricity of the 1980's, there are now much better analysis tools to resolve the issue fully, and its important to understand that not just our crystals are centrosymmetric, even the old guy's crystals were centrosymmetric (and by implication everyone's are). There is no shame in having made that error back in the day and those authors would not find the current centrosymmetric result controversial; their paper is excellent in all other aspects. This manuscript describes how the structure is determined, explains the structure schematically, calculates the electronic structure based on the correct centrosymmetric crystal structure, and gives the structural details that should be used for future analysis and modeling.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑