arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1311.7265stat.AP
收藏

估计半竞争性风险数据中受限制的平均工作任期以补偿歧视受害者

Estimating restricted mean job tenures in semi-competing risk data compensating victims of discrimination

Qing Pan, Joseph L. Gastwirth

摘要:

当原告在歧视案件中胜诉时,计算经济损失的一个主要组成部分是,如果他们在雇主实施歧视期间得到公平对待,他们本可以处于较高职位的时间长度。由于一个人的晋升资格因退休而终止,而且晋升和退休程序都可能受到歧视性做法的影响,这一问题变得更加复杂。这种半竞争性的风险设置被分解为员工的退休过程和晋升过程。为了补偿的目的,预测是通过利用不受歧视群体中类似资格的成员的预期晋升和退休概率来进行的。估计了三个时期的限制平均持续时间-雇员处于较低职位、处于较高职位和退休的时间。估计的渐近性质,并通过模拟研究。所提出的限制平均工作持续时间估计被证明是强大的存在下,一个独立的脆弱项。从反向歧视的情况下,亚历山大诉密尔沃基,其中白人男性中尉在晋升为队长歧视的数据进行了重新分析。虽然上诉法院支持赔偿责任,但它推翻了最初的损害计算,这在很大程度上取决于原告在每个位置上的时间。所提出的方法得到的结果进行了比较,在第一次审判。观察到两个方向的实质性差异。

英文摘要:

When plaintiffs prevail in a discrimination case, a major component of the calculation of economic loss is the length of time they would have been in the higher position had they been treated fairly during the period in which the employer practiced discrimination. This problem is complicated by the fact that one's eligibility for promotion is subject to termination by retirement and both the promotion and retirement processes may be affected by discriminatory practices. This semi-competing risk setup is decomposed into a retirement process and a promotion process among the employees. Predictions for the purpose of compensation are made by utilizing the expected promotion and retirement probabilities of similarly qualified members of the nondiscriminated group. The restricted mean durations of three periods are estimated - the time an employee would be at the lower position, at the higher level and in retirement. The asymptotic properties of the estimators are presented and examined through simulation studies. The proposed restricted mean job duration estimators are shown to be robust in the presence of an independent frailty term. Data from the reverse discrimination case, Alexander v. Milwaukee, where White-male lieutenants were discriminated in promotion to captain are reanalyzed. While the appellate court upheld liability, it reversed the original damage calculations, which heavily depended on the time a plaintiff would have been in each position. The results obtained by the proposed method are compared to those made at the first trial. Substantial differences in both directions are observed.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑