比较理论:词汇变化的动力学。相对论中的一个案例研究
Comparing theories: the dynamics of changing vocabulary. A case-study in relativity theory
摘要:
在文献中有几个一阶逻辑(FOL)对狭义相对论的公理化,它们看起来本质上不同,但声称公理化了同一个物理理论。本文在数理逻辑的框架下,对狭义相对论的FOL理论进行了比较。对于这种比较,我们使用一个版本的数学可定义性理论,其中新的实体也可以定义除了新的关系已经可用的实体。特别是,我们建立了一个解释的参考框架为导向的理论SpecRel到观测为导向的信号理论詹姆斯AX。这种解释为SpecRel提供了操作/实验语义。然后,我们通过使用定义等价的概念,对这两种理论进行精确的“定量”比较。这是在约翰·范·本瑟姆著作的精神下,逻辑在科学哲学和物理学中的应用。
英文摘要:
There are several first-order logic (FOL) axiomatizations of special relativity theory in the literature, all looking essentially different but claiming to axiomatize the same physical theory. In this paper, we elaborate a comparison, in the framework of mathematical logic, between these FOL theories for special relativity. For this comparison, we use a version of mathematical definability theory in which new entities can also be defined besides new relations over already available entities. In particular, we build an interpretation of the reference-frame oriented theory SpecRel into the observationally oriented Signalling theory of James Ax. This interpretation provides SpecRel with an operational/experimental semantics. Then we make precise, "quantitative" comparisons between these two theories via using the notion of definitional equivalence. This is an application of logic to the philosophy of science and physics in the spirit of Johan van Benthem's work.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。