AMR和SPH模拟的收敛性- I.流体动力学分辨率和收敛性试验
Convergence of AMR and SPH simulations - I. Hydrodynamical resolution and convergence tests
摘要:
我们比较了AMR有限体积代码,MG和SPH代码,SEREN进行的一组流体动力学试验的结果。该测试套件包括激波管测试,有和没有冷却,非线性薄壳不稳定性和开尔文-亥姆霍兹不稳定性。主要结论是:(1)在大多数情况下,两种方法在高分辨率和高精度范围内收敛。所有的测试显示良好的协议时,数值效应(如SPH中的不连续性)得到适当的处理。(ii)这两种方法都能很好地捕捉到绝热激波和分辨良好的冷却激波。然而,当处理高马赫数下的欠分辨冷却激波或严格等温激波时,它们都有问题。有限体积代码仅在一阶时工作良好,即使在一阶时也需要一些额外的人工粘性。SPH需要较大的人工粘度参数alpha_AV值,或者使用密度的调和平均值而不是算术平均值的标准人工粘度项的修改形式。(iii)一些SPH模拟需要更大的内核,以增加邻居的数量和减少粒子噪声,以实现与有限体积模拟协议。然而,这在一定程度上是由于需要减少可能破坏小尺度扰动增长的噪声。相比之下,种子从大规模扰动不稳定性不需要更多的邻居,因此与标准的SPH公式和收敛的有限体积模拟。(iv)对于纯粹的流体动力学问题,SPH模拟比有限体积模拟在同等分辨率下运行时要长一个数量级,即当它们都以相同的程度解决基础物理时。这需要大约2-3倍于细胞数量的颗粒。
英文摘要:
We compare the results for a set of hydrodynamical tests performed with the AMR finite volume code, MG and the SPH code, SEREN. The test suite includes shock tube tests, with and without cooling, the non-linear thin-shell instability and the Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. The main conclusions are : (i) the two methods converge in the limit of high resolution and accuracy in most cases. All tests show good agreement when numerical effects (e.g. discontinuities in SPH) are properly treated. (ii) Both methods can capture adiabatic shocks and well-resolved cooling shocks perfectly well with standard prescriptions. However, they both have problems when dealing with under-resolved cooling shocks, or strictly isothermal shocks, at high Mach numbers. The finite volume code only works well at 1st order and even then requires some additional artificial viscosity. SPH requires either a larger value of the artificial viscosity parameter, alpha_AV, or a modified form of the standard artificial viscosity term using the harmonic mean of the density, rather than the arithmetic mean. (iii) Some SPH simulations require larger kernels to increase neighbour number and reduce particle noise in order to achieve agreement with finite volume simulations. However, this is partly due to the need to reduce noise that can corrupt the growth of small-scale perturbations. In contrast, instabilities seeded from large-scale perturbations do not require more neighbours and hence work well with standard SPH formulations and converge with the finite volume simulations. (iv) For purely hydrodynamical problems, SPH simulations take an order of magnitude longer to run than finite volume simulations when running at equivalent resolutions, i.e. when they both resolve the underlying physics to the same degree. This requires about 2-3 times as many particles as the number of cells.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。