不同不确定性推理系统构造的专家系统的比较
Comparing Expert Systems Built Using Different Uncertain Inference Systems
摘要:
本研究比较了专家系统中管理不确定性的最主要方法的固有直观性或可用性,包括EMYCIN、PROSPECTOR、Dempster-Shafer理论、模糊集理论、简化概率论(假设边缘独立性)和使用概率估计的线性回归。参与者通过一系列的学习试验,在一个简单的假设问题领域获得了经验。然后,他们被随机分配到开发一个专家系统使用上述六个不确定推理系统(UIS)之一。然后比较所得系统的性能。结果表明,基于PROSPECTOR和EMYCIN模型的系统对于某些类型的问题的准确性明显低于基于其他UIS的系统。这些差异的可能原因进行了讨论。
英文摘要:
This study compares the inherent intuitiveness or usability of the most prominent methods for managing uncertainty in expert systems, including those of EMYCIN, PROSPECTOR, Dempster-Shafer theory, fuzzy set theory, simplified probability theory (assuming marginal independence), and linear regression using probability estimates. Participants in the study gained experience in a simple, hypothetical problem domain through a series of learning trials. They were then randomly assigned to develop an expert system using one of the six Uncertain Inference Systems (UISs) listed above. Performance of the resulting systems was then compared. The results indicate that the systems based on the PROSPECTOR and EMYCIN models were significantly less accurate for certain types of problems compared to systems based on the other UISs. Possible reasons for these differences are discussed.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。