arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1301.2522cs.DLcs.CY
收藏

科学3.0:对科学2.0范式的修正

Science 3.0: Corrections to the Science 2.0 paradigm

Vladimir B. Teif

摘要:

“科学2.0”的概念是在近十年前提出的,旨在描述新一代基于在线的研究工具,使研究人员能够更轻松地进行数据共享、协作和出版。虽然技术上是合理的,但这个概念仍然不能像预期的那样工作。在这里,我们提供了一个系统的论点来修改科学2.0的概念,使其更符合科学和互联网的精神和传统。我们对科学2.0范式的第一个修正涉及向作者收取费用的开放获取出版模式。正如在其他地方讨论的那样,我们表明,这种出版模式的垄断增加了基于作者收入的科学思想的代表性的偏见和不平等。我们的第二个更正涉及在线发表后的评论,在当前的科学2.0范式中,这些评论基本上都是非匿名的。我们的结论是,科学出版后的讨论需要特殊的匿名系统。我们进一步分析了当前出版后同行评议模式失败的原因,并提出了在科学3.0中需要改变的地方,以将互联网转变为一个大型期刊俱乐部。

英文摘要:

The concept of Science 2.0 was introduced almost a decade ago to describe the new generation of online-based tools for researchers allowing easier data sharing, collaboration and publishing. Although technically sound, the concept still does not work as expected. Here we provide a systematic line of arguments to modify the concept of Science 2.0, making it more consistent with the spirit and traditions of science and Internet. Our first correction to the Science 2.0 paradigm concerns the open-access publication models charging fees to the authors. As discussed elsewhere, we show that the monopoly of such publishing models increases biases and inequalities in the representation of scientific ideas based on the author's income. Our second correction concerns post-publication comments online, which are all essentially non-anonymous in the current Science 2.0 paradigm. We conclude that scientific post-publication discussions require special anonymization systems. We further analyze the reasons of the failure of the current post-publication peer-review models and suggest what needs to be changed in Science 3.0 to convert Internet into a large journal club.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑