arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1208.3292stat.ME
收藏

对J. J. Goeman和A.索拉里

Discussion of "Multiple Testing for Exploratory Research" by J. J. Goeman and A. Solari

Ruth Heller

摘要:

Goeman和Solari [统计学家。Sci. 26(2011)584-597,arXiv:1208.2841]已经解决了探索性研究的多重检验这一有趣的话题,并为探索性分析提供了很好的建议。他们定义了探索性分析的推理程序应该具有的属性:程序应该温和,灵活和事后。他们的推理过程给出了一个下界的数量假假设之间的选定的假设,而且只要有可能确定基本假设是假的。在各种应用中出现了估计错误假设的数量的下限的需要,并且在Biometrics 64(2008)1215-1222中为此目的开发了部分合取方法(还参见Philos.Trans.R.2008)。Soc. Lond. A 367(2009)4255-4271,以获得更多细节)。例如,在对研究同一问题的几项研究进行综合分析时,有必要给出一个关于重复该发现的研究数量的下限。我将首先说明戈曼和索拉里的方法与部分合取方法之间的关系。然后,我将讨论可能的扩展,并解决在更一般的设置探索的问题,其中本地测试可能没有预先定义或候选假设可能不知道开始。

英文摘要:

Goeman and Solari [Statist. Sci. 26 (2011) 584-597, arXiv:1208.2841] have addressed the interesting topic of multiple testing for exploratory research, and provided us with nice suggestions for exploratory analysis. They defined properties that an inferential procedure should have for exploratory analysis: the procedure should be mild, flexible and post hoc. Their inferential procedure gives a lower bound on the number of false hypotheses among the selected hypotheses, and moreover whenever possible identifies elementary hypotheses that are false. The need to estimate a lower bound on the number of false hypotheses arises in various applications, and the partial conjunction approach was developed for this purpose in Biometrics 64 (2008) 1215-1222 (see also Philos. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A 367 (2009) 4255-4271 for more details). For example, in a combined analysis of several studies that examine the same problem, it is of interest to give a lower bound on the number of studies in which the finding was reproduced. I will first address the relation between the method of Goeman and Solari and the partial conjunction approach. Then I will discuss possible extensions and address the issue of exploration in more general settings, where the local test may not be defined in advance or where the candidate hypotheses may not be known to begin with.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑