arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1207.5294physics.hist-phphysics.comp-phphysics.ed-phquant-ph
收藏

量子兰迪挑战

Quantum Randi Challenge

Sascha Vongehr

摘要:

观察到的贝尔型不等式的违反排除了所有相对论微观因果(“本地”),反事实的明确(“真正的”)隐藏的变量模型的性质。我们对实在概念的进一步相对化引发了对量子力学日益增长的伪科学抵制。我通过五个特征定义了教学兰迪挑战(DRC)。根据自然法则,这些挑战是不可能应对的。他们有效地驳斥了伪科学的主张,根据这些主张,挑战可以很容易地得到满足。DRC的工作原理是,尽管迎接挑战会带来巨大的回报,但它的存在却从未被克服。伪科学利用善意的参与来制造专家争论的假象(播种怀疑)。刚果民主共和国拒绝讨论“直到挑战得到满足”,而没有巩固建立阴谋的看法。这需要透明度,因此DRC是有效的教学工具。量子兰迪挑战赛(QRC)是一个DRC,旨在通过简单地教授QM来拒绝隐变量模型;没有赌注或与挑战者的互动。QRC是一款任何人都可以修改的电脑游戏。目前的版本包括一个真正的QM行为的模拟,违反贝尔99%的时间,违反贝尔和CHSH不等式的隐藏变量的50%的概率,和违反贝尔85%的时间时,失踪13%的反相关。DRC的挑战是修改隐变量,以便出现预测的QM行为,包括反相关。如果这是可能的,那么所提出的程序将使应对挑战变得微不足道。这一事实和整个QRC可以教给广大观众通过所提出的知识。要求反相关被认为是优于采用CHSH。

英文摘要:

Observed violations of Bell type inequalities exclude all relativistic micro causal ("local"), counterfactual definite ("real") hidden variable models of nature. This further relativization of our concept of reality triggers a growing pseudoscientific resistance against quantum mechanics (QM). I define Didactic Randi Challenges (DRC) via five characteristics. These are challenges which, according to the laws of nature, are impossible to meet. They effectively refute pseudoscientific claims according to which the challenge could easily be met. DRC work by being known to exist while never having been overcome, despite the large rewards which would follow from meeting the challenge. Pseudoscience exploits well meaning engagement in argument to create the appearance of an expert dispute (sowing doubt). DRC decline to discuss "until the challenge is met", without solidifying the perception of establishment conspiracy. This requires transparency, thus DRC are efficient didactic tools. The Quantum Randi Challenge (QRC) is a DRC designed to reject hidden variable models by simply teaching QM; there is no bet or interaction with challengers. The QRC is a computer game that anybody can modify. The present version includes a simulation of true QM behavior that violates Bell 99% of the time, hidden variables that violate the Bell and CHSH inequality with 50% probability, and ones which violate Bell 85% of the time when missing 13% anti-correlation. The DRC challenge is to modify the hidden variables so that the predicted QM behavior arises, including anti-correlation. If such were possible, the presented programs would make it trivial to meet the challenge. This fact and the whole QRC can be taught to a wide audience via the presented heuristics. Demanding anti-correlation is argued to be superior to employing CHSH.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑