arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1206.4386q-bio.PEnlin.AOq-bio.NC
收藏

文化的进化框架:选择主义与公共交换

An Evolutionary Framework for Culture: Selectionism versus Communal Exchange

Liane Gabora

摘要:

道金斯基于复制器的进化观导致了选择论在社会科学中的广泛误用,因为它没有解决最初启发自然选择理论的悖论:当生物体一生中获得的特征被抹去时,生物体如何积累变化?冯·诺依曼提出了自我复制自动机(SRA)的概念。SRA由自组装代码组成,以两种不同的方式使用:(1)在开发过程中主动破译以构建自相似的复制品,以及(2)被动复制到复制品以确保它可以复制。在一生中获得的信息不会传递给后代,而在复制过程中继承的信息则会传递。在文化进化中,没有抛弃后天变化的机制。获得性变化可以比遗传性变化更快地积累数量级,并迅速压倒遗传性变化,这是由于变异体响应选择的差异复制。这禁止了选择论,但不是文化的进化框架。最近关于生命起源的研究表明,早期生命是通过一个非达尔文的过程进化而来的,这个过程被称为公共交换,不涉及自我组装代码,自然选择是从这个更偶然的祖先进化过程中出现的。公共交换理论为文化提供了一个比选择论更合适的进化框架。这得到了文化进化的计算模型和基于网络的记录物质文化历史的程序的支持,并且与人类的高水平合作是一致的。

英文摘要:

Dawkins' replicator-based conception of evolution has led to widespread mis-application selectionism across the social sciences because it does not address the paradox that inspired the theory of natural selection in the first place: how do organisms accumulate change when traits acquired over their lifetime are obliterated? This is addressed by von Neumann's concept of a self-replicating automaton (SRA). A SRA consists of a self-assembly code that is used in two distinct ways: (1) actively deciphered during development to construct a self-similar replicant, and (2) passively copied to the replicant to ensure that it can reproduce. Information that is acquired over a lifetime is not transmitted to offspring, whereas information that is inherited during copying is transmitted. In cultural evolution there is no mechanism for discarding acquired change. Acquired change can accumulate orders of magnitude faster than, and quickly overwhelm, inherited change due to differential replication of variants in response to selection. This prohibits a selectionist but not an evolutionary framework for culture. Recent work on the origin of life suggests that early life evolved through a non-Darwinian process referred to as communal exchange that does not involve a self-assembly code, and that natural selection emerged from this more haphazard, ancestral evolutionary process. It is proposed that communal exchange provides a more appropriate evolutionary framework for culture than selectionism. This is supported by a computational model of cultural evolution and a network-based program for documenting material cultural history, and it is consistent with high levels of human cooperation.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑