arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1206.3027cs.CYcs.SIphysics.soc-ph
收藏

社交网络、社会功能分化与数据保护

Social Networks, Functional Differentiation of Society, and Data Protection

Jörg Pohle

摘要:

大多数学者、政治家和活动家都遵循个人主义的隐私和数据保护理论。相比之下,德国数据保护立法的一些先驱,如Adalbert Podlech,Paul J. Müller和Ulrich Dammann,使用了系统理论方法。继Niklas Luhmann之后,数据保护的目标是:(1)维持社会的功能分化,以应对现代信息处理的可能性所带来的威胁;(2)对抗有组织的社会参与者的不当信息权力。因此,毫不奇怪,德国黑森州的第一部数据保护法律包含了保护个人以及国家立法和行政机构之间权力平衡的规则。像Facebook或Google+这样的社交网络不仅会通过将用户暴露给其他用户或公众来危及他们的用户。它们首先对整个社会构成威胁,因为它们收集来自不同社会制度的个人、群体和组织的信息,并将它们合并到一个集中的数据库中。它们超越了社会制度之间的界限,这些制度是个人完全透明和透明的屏障,保护人民的自由和自主。如果不对社交网络本身或其背后的公司对收集到的数据的组织使用实施结构性限制,社交网络将给西方社会带来自苏联解体以来最严重的极权主义危险。

英文摘要:

Most scholars, politicians, and activists are following individualistic theories of privacy and data protection. In contrast, some of the pioneers of the data protection legislation in Germany like Adalbert Podlech, Paul J. Müller, and Ulrich Dammann used a systems theory approach. Following Niklas Luhmann, the aim of data protection is (1) maintaining the functional differentiation of society against the threats posed by the possibilities of modern information processing, and (2) countering undue information power by organized social players. It could be, therefore, no surprise that the first data protection law in the German state of Hesse contained rules to protect the individual as well as the balance of power between the legislative and the executive body of the state. Social networks like Facebook or Google+ do not only endanger their users by exposing them to other users or the public. They constitute, first and foremost, a threat to society as a whole by collecting information about individuals, groups, and organizations from different social systems and combining them in a centralized data bank. They transgress the boundaries between social systems that act as a shield against total visibility and transparency of the individual and protect the freedom and the autonomy of the people. Without enforcing structural limitations on the organizational use of collected data by the social network itself or the company behind it, social networks pose the worst totalitarian peril for western societies since the fall of the Soviet Union.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑