arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1205.3290stat.MEphysics.data-an
收藏

Newcomb-Benford定律的快速异常检测及其在USA、波多黎各和委内瑞拉选举过程数据中的应用

Quick Anomaly Detection by the Newcomb--Benford Law, with Applications to Electoral Processes Data from the USA, Puerto Rico and Venezuela

Luis Pericchi, David Torres

摘要:

本文提出了一种简便、快速的数值异常通用检验方法。例如,它可以应用于电子和手工选举进程。它使用官方公布的投票单位中的投票计数,这些投票单位通常广泛使用并得到机构的支持。该测试检查了投票计数数字的频率,并依赖于第一位数(NBL 1)和第二位数纽科姆-本福德定律(NBL 2),以及在每单位最大投票人数限制下的新概括(RNBL 2)。我们将测试应用于2004年美国总统选举,波多黎各(1996年,2000年和2004年)州长选举,2004年委内瑞拉总统罢免公投(RRP)和以前的2000年委内瑞拉总统选举。NBL 2仅在委内瑞拉公投中被强制拒绝,并且仅适用于电子投票单位。我们最初关于RRP的建议(Pericchi和Torres,2004)受到卡特中心报告(2005)的批评。认识到这一点,Mebane(2006)和The Economist(US)(2007)提出了支持NBL 2的投票模型和案例研究。进一步的证据在这里。此外,在RNBL 2下,Mebane的投票模型在更广泛的条件下有效。通过贝叶斯因子(和$p$值的校正)而不是显著性检验评估该定律的充分性,因为对于大样本量和固定$α$水平,原假设被过度拒绝。我们的测试非常简单,可以成为一个公平的选举过程应该通过的标准筛选。

英文摘要:

A simple and quick general test to screen for numerical anomalies is presented. It can be applied, for example, to electoral processes, both electronic and manual. It uses vote counts in officially published voting units, which are typically widely available and institutionally backed. The test examines the frequencies of digits on voting counts and rests on the First (NBL1) and Second Digit Newcomb--Benford Law (NBL2), and in a novel generalization of the law under restrictions of the maximum number of voters per unit (RNBL2). We apply the test to the 2004 USA presidential elections, the Puerto Rico (1996, 2000 and 2004) governor elections, the 2004 Venezuelan presidential recall referendum (RRP) and the previous 2000 Venezuelan Presidential election. The NBL2 is compellingly rejected only in the Venezuelan referendum and only for electronic voting units. Our original suggestion on the RRP (Pericchi and Torres, 2004) was criticized by The Carter Center report (2005). Acknowledging this, Mebane (2006) and The Economist (US) (2007) presented voting models and case studies in favor of NBL2. Further evidence is presented here. Moreover, under the RNBL2, Mebane's voting models are valid under wider conditions. The adequacy of the law is assessed through Bayes Factors (and corrections of $p$-values) instead of significance testing, since for large sample sizes and fixed $α$ levels the null hypothesis is over rejected. Our tests are extremely simple and can become a standard screening that a fair electoral process should pass.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑