临界跃迁早期预警检测的量化限度
Quantifying Limits to Detection of Early Warning for Critical Transitions
摘要:
复杂自然系统中的灾难性政权转移可以通过先进的检测来避免。最近的工作提供了一个原理证明,即许多接近灾难性转变的系统可以通过早期预警指标(如方差上升或返回时间增加)来识别。尽管普遍认识到这种预测的困难和不确定性,提出的方法几乎从来没有表征其预期的错误率。如果没有重复、控制或事后诸葛亮的好处,这些方法的应用必须量化不同指标在避免误报方面的可靠性,以及它们对遗漏细微警告信号的敏感性。我们提出了一个基于模型的方法,以量化可靠性和灵敏度之间的权衡,并允许不同的指标之间的比较。我们表明,即使在有利的假设下,这些错误率对于常见指标也可能相当严重,并且还说明了基于模型的指标如何提高这种性能。我们展示了预警指标的表现如何在不同的数据集不同,并建议不确定性量化成为预警预测的一个更核心的部分。
英文摘要:
Catastrophic regime shifts in complex natural systems may be averted through advanced detection. Recent work has provided a proof-of-principle that many systems approaching a catastrophic transition may be identified through the lens of early warning indicators such as rising variance or increased return times. Despite widespread appreciation of the difficulties and uncertainty involved in such forecasts, proposed methods hardly ever characterize their expected error rates. Without the benefits of replicates, controls, or hindsight, applications of these approaches must quantify how reliable different indicators are in avoiding false alarms, and how sensitive they are to missing subtle warning signs. We propose a model based approach in order to quantify this trade-off between reliability and sensitivity and allow comparisons between different indicators. We show these error rates can be quite severe for common indicators even under favorable assumptions, and also illustrate how a model-based indicator can improve this performance. We demonstrate how the performance of an early warning indicator varies in different data sets, and suggest that uncertainty quantification become a more central part of early warning predictions.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。