“铊的电偶极矩增强因子”简评
Brief remarks on "Electric dipole moment enhancement factor of thallium"
摘要:
在Porsev等人[arXiv:1201.5615v1]最近的一篇论文中,作者声称已经解决了由Tl的EDM增强因子的不同从头计算结果引起的争议。我们认为,要想解决不同计算之间的差异,就必须彻底比较两种不同情况下所使用的基组、所采用的方法和所考虑的近似值。然而,Porsev等人在他们目前的论文中没有成功地做到这一点。我们在本说明中澄清他们对我们工作的一些误解,并解决一些具体问题。
英文摘要:
In a recent paper by Porsev et al. [arXiv:1201.5615v1], the authors have claimed to have resolved the controversy arising from the different ab initio results available for the EDM enhancement factor of Tl. In our opinion, any such attempt to resolve the discrepancies between different calculations has to thoroughly compare the basis sets used, methods employed and approximations considered in the two different cases. However, Porsev et al. have not succeeded in doing so in their current paper. We clarify some of their misunderstandings about our work and address some specific issues in this note.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。