为微调的谬误辩护
Defending The Fallacy of Fine-Tuning
摘要:
2011年,我出版了一本通俗读物《微调的谬误:为什么宇宙不是为我们设计的》。它调查了在当代宗教文献中发现的一种常见说法,即物理学和宇宙学的参数是如此微妙地平衡,如此“微调”,以至于宇宙中任何轻微的变化和生命都是不可能的。我的结论是,虽然我们在地球上发现的生命形式不会在这些参数发生微小变化的情况下存在,但某种形式的生命可能已经在一个参数范围内进化,而不是像人们常说的那样,是无限小的。博士后研究员Luke Barnes撰写了一篇冗长的、高度技术性的评论[arXiv:1112.4647],内容是关于微调问题的科学文献。我对这些文献没有重大的异议,也没有任何著名的物理学家或宇宙学家对我的基本结论提出异议。巴恩斯并没有使这些结论无效,并坚持和歪曲了书中的大部分内容。
英文摘要:
In 2011, I published a popular-level book, The Fallacy of Fine-Tuning: Why the Universe is Not Designed for Us. It investigated a common claim found in contemporary religious literature that the parameters of physics and cosmology are so delicately balanced, so "fine-tuned," that any slight change and life in the universe would have been impossible. I concluded that while the precise form of life we find on Earth would not exist with slight changes in these parameters, some form of life could have evolved over a parameter range that is not infinitesimal, as often claimed. Postdoctoral fellow Luke Barnes has written a lengthy, highly technical review [arXiv:1112.4647] of the scientific literature on the fine-tuning problem. I have no significant disagreement with that literature and no prominent physicist or cosmologist has disputed my basic conclusions. Barnes does not invalidate these conclusions and misunderstands and misrepresents much of what is in the book.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。