对“揭示氢在Cu2O中的复杂行为“一文的评论
Comment on "Uncovering the Complex Behavior of Hydrogen in Cu2O"
摘要:
在最近的一封信中,Scanlon和Watson报告了他们关于Cu 2 O中氢的第一原理结果。他们的主要结论是:(1)Cu 2 O中的间隙H优先占据四面体位置,该四面体位置与四个Cu阳离子配位,在所有三种电荷状态(+1、中性和-1)下;(2)H将与Cu空位结合并形成电活性H-VCu缺陷复合物,该复合物是两性的,分别在Ev + 0.1和Ev + 1.1 eV处具有(+/0)和(0/-)跃迁能级。然而,这两个结论与H在氧化物中的两个普遍观察到的行为相矛盾:(i)阳离子H通常与O原子结合,形成单一的O-H键,而阴离子H通常与多配位的阳离子结合;(ii)H通常钝化氧化物中的阳离子空位。在这篇评论中,我们明确地表明,与电荷状态+1,H更喜欢与一个单一的O阴离子,而不是与四个Cu阳离子结合,H-VCu不诱导任何缺陷的带隙内的水平。
英文摘要:
In a recent Letter Scanlon and Watson reported their first principles results on hydrogen in Cu2O. Their main conclusions are: (1) an interstitial H in Cu2O prefers to occupy the tetrahedral site, which is coordinated with four Cu cations, in all three charge states (+1, neutral, and -1); (2) H will bind with a Cu vacancy and form an electrically active H-VCu defect complex, which is amphoteric with (+/0) and (0/-)transition levels at Ev + 0.1 and Ev + 1.1 eV, respectively. However, these two conclusions contradict two generally observed behaviors of H in oxides: (i) cationic H usually binds with an O atom, forming a single O-H bond, while the anionic H usually binds with cations with multi-coordination; (ii) H usually passivates cation vacancies in oxides. In this Comment, we explicitly show that with charge state +1, H prefers to bind with a single O anion rather than with four Cu cations and that H-VCu does not induce any defect levels inside the band gap.
机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。