arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv周末暂无论文更新,休息一下吧,周末愉快~~
arXiv 1112.4347astro-ph.HE
收藏

Amati关系用于宇宙学目的的一个重要问题

A Significant Problem With Using the Amati Relation for Cosmological Purposes

Andrew C. Collazzi, Bradley E. Schaefer, Adam Goldstein, Robert D. Preece

摘要:

我们考虑了许多伽马射线暴(GRB)样品的分布,将它们的辐射热通量(Sbolo)与观测到的峰值谱通量光子能量(Epeak,obs)绘制成图。在这个图中,服从阿马蒂关系的爆发必须位于某个极限线之上,尽管观测到的散射预计是相当大的。我们证实,早期爆发的光谱红移是符合这个限制。但是,我们发现BATSE,Swift,Suzaku和Konus的爆发都大大违反了极限。在Sbolo-Epeak,obs图中,我们发现每个卫星都有很大不同的分布。这就要求选择效应在这些分布中占主导地位,这是我们确定的。对于探测器选择,触发阈值和测量Epeak,obs的阈值结合起来形成对角截止,该截止的位置在探测器之间变化很大。对于由于爆发群体的固有性质而产生的选择效应,Epeak,obs的分布使得具有低和高值的爆发罕见,而注量分布使得明亮的爆发罕见。对于一个差的阈值,选择效应的组合只允许测量沿着极限的区域内的爆发;这些爆发将遵循阿马蒂关系。因此,Amati关系是爆发群和检测器内选择效应的伪影。因此,阿马蒂关系不应该被用于宇宙学任务。这个失败对其他光度关系没有任何损害。

英文摘要:

We consider the distribution of many samples of Gamma-Ray Bursts (GRBs) when plotted in a diagram with their bolometric fluence (Sbolo) versus the observed photon energy of peak spectral flux (Epeak,obs). In this diagram, bursts that obey the Amati relation must lie above some limiting line, although observational scatter is expected to be substantial. We confirm that early bursts with spectroscopic redshifts are consistent with this limit. But, we find that the bursts from BATSE, Swift, Suzaku, and Konus are all greatly in violation of the limit. In the Sbolo-Epeak,obs diagram, we find that every satellite has a greatly different distribution. This requires that selection effects are dominating these distributions, which we identify. For detector selections, the trigger threshold and the threshold to measure Epeak,obs combine to make a diagonal cutoff with the position of this cutoff varying greatly detector to detector. For selection effects due to the intrinsic properties of the burst population, the distribution of Epeak,obs makes for bursts with low and high values to be rare, while the fluence distribution makes bright bursts uncommon. For a poor threshold, the combination of selection effects serves to allow only bursts within a region along the limit to be measured; these bursts will then appear to follow an Amati relation. Therefore, the Amati relation is an artifact of selection effects within the burst population and the detector. Therefore, the Amati relation should not be used for cosmological tasks. This failure is in no way prejudicial against the other luminosity relations.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑