arXivDaily arXiv每日学术速递 周一至周五更新
arXiv 1110.2697astro-ph.SR
收藏

对“解决太阳矢量磁场数据中的180度模糊性:评估噪声、空间分辨率和方法假设的影响”的评论“的回应

Response to "Comment on `Resolving the 180deg Ambiguity in Solar Vector Magnetic Field Data: Evaluating the Effects of Noise, Spatial Resolution, and Method Assumptions'"

K. D. Leka, Graham Barnes, G. Allen Gary, A. D. Crouch, Y. Liu

摘要:

我们讨论了最近在Georgoulis(2011)中讨论的Leka等人(2009 b)的观点。最重要的是,我们发现Georgoulis(2011)的结果支持Leka等人(2009 b)的结论:有限的空间分辨率和未分辨的磁性结构的存在可能会挑战模糊度-分辨率算法。此外,Metcalf等人(2006)和Leka等人(2009 b)的发现在Georgoulis(2011)中得到了证实:当观测场不符合该方法的假设时,该方法的性能可能会降低。讨论了边界在太阳磁结构模型中的含义;我们确认Leka等人(2009 b)使用的模型中的场分量分布比Georgoulis(2011)提出的更接近太阳上观测到的分布。它也表明,该方法确实重要的模拟有限的空间分辨率和避免无意中引入的偏见。最后,分配类别的数据分析算法被重新审视,我们认为,分配是有用的,只有当使用适当的说明。

英文摘要:

We address points recently discussed in Georgoulis (2011) in reference to Leka et al. (2009b). Most importantly, we find that the results of Georgoulis (2011) support a conclusion of Leka et al. (2009b): that limited spatial resolution and the presence of unresolved magnetic structures can challenge ambiguity- resolution algorithms. Moreover, the findings of both Metcalf et al. (2006) and Leka et al. (2009b) are confirmed in Georgoulis (2011): a method's performance can be diminished when the observed field fails to conform to that method's assumptions. The implication of boundaries in models of solar magnetic structures is discussed; we confirm that the distribution of the field components in the model used in Leka et al. (2009b) is closer to what is observed on the Sun than what is proposed in Georgoulis (2011). It is also shown that method does matter with regards to simulating limited spatial resolution and avoiding an inadvertent introduction of bias. Finally, the assignment of categories to data- analysis algorithms is revisited; we argue that assignments are only useful and elucidating when used appropriately.

机构、总结、中文摘要均由AI分析而来,可能存在错误,请以论文正文为准。

↑